M | T | W | T | F | S | S |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
« Feb | ||||||
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |||
5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 |
12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 |
19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 |
26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Simon Phipps on ☆ Sunday Cabbage | |
Bart Smaalders on ☆ Sunday Cabbage | |
Mark Wielaard on ☝ OIN’s New Linux Defini… | |
Simon Phipps on ☝ OIN’s New Linux Defini… | |
Mark Wielaard on ☝ OIN’s New Linux Defini… | |
Ian Davis on ☝ Why I Want My Pi | |
Links – Educat… on ☆ IPEG-SA Announces Tapeworm… |
☝ | My articles elsewhere |
☞ | Daily links |
☆ | New articles posted here |
☂ | Site news |
✈ | Travel-related |
♫ | Music-related |
⚡ | Tweets |
The Hobbit is one of our local pubs. It’s a rather seedy student-focussed music venue that serves cheap booze under fanciful names taken from Tolkein’s books. Their web site is full of publicity material derived from the Lord of the Rings movies. I had always wondered how they managed to license the Hobbit trademarks from their owners and now we know. They didn’t. And the Nazgûl have come home to roost.
This turns out to be quite an interesting case. In terms of trademark law for the name and copyright law for the recycled movie stills, I’ve little doubt the pub are in the wrong and have had this coming for a long time (possibly so long that if they went to court they might make a case that the trademarks have been abandoned…) But in terms of popular culture, there’s an arguable case that Tolkein’s work now forms a cultural bedrock in the UK that should allow the names and ideas it has popularised to be used freely.
This is one of the areas I think we have a problem with current copyright and trademark law. It’s all framed by short-term thinking where every motive is a business motive of comparable scale and intent. It has no trapdoor for modern cultural artefacts – the songs that have entered the national psyche, the stories that have become every child’s nursery, the images that wallpaper everyone’s memory – to be released from the dragon’s grip and mutate from wealth artefact into cultural jewel.
Worse, the trend is in the opposite direction – longer monopolies, more draconian punishments for violating them (even unknowingly), the permanent annexation of popular culture by the companies lucky enough to have got away with stealing it before the law got this way. The idea of these ‘intellectual monopolies’ being a temporary gift to further the public good is all but lost, especially in the minds of the companies getting rich from them.
So while I don’t think the pub has a chance, I do think it’s worth highlighting the case in public. Sometimes the public good is served by the end of monopolies rather than by their continuation. As a friend said, can you imagine how Britain would be if Shakespeare’s estate still controlled all his works?
Filed under: Trademarks | Tagged: Lord of the Rings, Southampton, Trademark | Leave a Comment »
Yahoo’s litigation against Facebook is one more example in an unending sequence that demonstrates patents are now primarily a weapon to chill competition rather than a protection for innovation. Read more over at ComputerWorldUK.
Filed under: ComputerWorldUK | Leave a Comment »
You may have spotted two posts by me on InfoWorld in the US recently (one about LibreOffice and one about OIN). I’m pleased to say that I was approached by them to take over the widely-read “Open Sources” column. Naturally I accepted their proposal and I hope to write every Friday for them. Thanks to Savio Rodrigues for the excellent work he has done to build the readership there – those will be big shoes to fill. All story ideas welcome!
Filed under: InfoWorld, Webmink | Leave a Comment »
Kiva are giving away $25 to anyone who asks today. It’s true. The catch? You have to loan the money to someone who has far, far less money than you do and who will use it to bootstrap their business. Like everything, Kiva has a deeper story, but I am an enthusiastic supporter as I believe investing in local small entrepreneurs who will grow their economy is by far the best way to tackle poverty long-term.
I recommend you go to their site and claim your $25. Be quick, these offers “sell out” amazingly fast. First-time Kiva lenders only, obviously.