« Google Book Search: Using Mass Piracy To Dominate Internet Markets and Cripple Law-Abiding Competition Held Unfair, Unreasonable, and Illegal.
FTC’s Google Buzz Settlement Is a Start »

Blocking Traffic Apps Trapster and PhantomALERT is Misguided

Today, Senators Reid, Schumer, Lautenberg and Udall released a letter they sent to mobile applications stores asking them to block distribution of traffic software apps like Trapster and PhantomALERT because user-generated input can warn drivers about drunk driving checkpoints.

While I applaud the Senators for seeking to curb drunk driving, their criticism of online traffic apps misses the point.  These programs feature information about speed and red light cameras by mapping publicly available information provided by law enforcement agencies.  There is also a social networking element of the apps which allows users to submit traffic information so drivers can avoid traffic jams.  This makes these programs very popular attracting tens of millions of users. Law enforcement authorities have embraced these services expressing their strong approval for products that reduce speeding and improve traffic safety.

These traffic apps rely on user-submitted and law enforcement provided information.  Any one of the programs’ users can submit a warning about a traffic obstruction as simply as emailing a friend or posting a message on their Facebook profile. The suggestion that the government should compel Apple, RIM, or other mobile application stores to block programs that simply allow users to report information based on location is misguided at best. Taken to its conclusion, that would require blocking apps like Foursquare and Loopt.  Having the government act as arbiter of which products should be sold in stores is a slippery slope that few would welcome.

This entry was posted on Wednesday, March 23rd, 2011 at 3:19 pm and is filed under Current Affairs, Featured, Tech Regulation. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

One Response to “Blocking Traffic Apps Trapster and PhantomALERT is Misguided”

  1. Collecting and Sharing Data is a Good Thing « Paul Carney says:
    March 25, 2011 at 10:01 am

    [...] the needs of small business innovators from around the world, describes in better detail why this activity is misguided. The government should not be allowed to tell businesses, on a wholesale and vague level, what [...]

Leave a Reply

Click here to cancel reply.