About
Subscribe
Subscribe in a reader
Categories
- 24/7 Real Media
- Advertising
- Amazon
- AOL
- Apple
- aQuantive
- CBS
- Click Fraud
- Comcast
- Dead-Tree Media
- Digital Music
- Digressions
- Dow Jones
- eBay
- eBay-Skype
- eCommerce
- Genius Awards
- Google v. Microsoft
- Hakia
- IAC
- Internet
- Internet Outsider
- Joost
- LoopNet
- Mahalo
- Microsoft
- MySpace
- News Corp.
- Newspapers
- Nutrisystems
- Omniture
- Online Meets TV
- Overstock
- Pay-Per-Call
- Powerset
- Search
- Skype
- Spyware, Traffic Boosters, and Other Sleaze
- TechTarget
- The Dismal Science
- TheStreet.com
- Time Warner
- Time Warner Hocks AOL
- TiVo
- User Generated Content
- ValueClick
- VOIP Wars
- VUDU
- Wall Street Research
- WebSideStory
- Why I Don't Own Google
- Yahoo!
Recent Comments
- A Facebook User on Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- A Facebook User on Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- A Facebook User on Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- Murat Başer on Recession Watch: We're Probably Already in One
- Murat Başer on Recession Watch: We're Probably Already in One
- Claire Homes on UK Online Ads Pass Newspapers; U.S. Online Ad Spending to Triple?
- Michael Nelson on Why Did Google Invest in Sergey's Wife's Start-Up?
- Abir1lemon on Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- Abd Sakib on Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- Isabella Das on VCs Cry Boo-Hoo, Refuse to Pay Income Tax
Recent Posts
- Trust Me, You Don't Want To Miss This One (Fox Business News on Apple's AMD Deal)
- Microsoft Hallucinating? Or Planning to Buy Yahoo?
- Recession Watch: We're Probably Already in One
- Okay, I'm Back. Thanks for the Patience.
- Play the Google Earnings Sweepstakes!
- Yahoo (YHOO): Q3 Stronger Than Expected
- Where I've Gone...
- Internet Recession Watch: Google Sees Ad Cutbacks
- Google Not "Immune" to Mortgage Crisis
- Yahoo (YHOO) Traffic Grinds to Halt: Fat Lady Singing?
Archives
- November 2007
- October 2007
- September 2007
- August 2007
- July 2007
- June 2007
- May 2007
- April 2007
- March 2007
- February 2007
Resources
« Lazard / Icahn Right About AOL | Main | We Aren't Fa-mi-ly! TWC vs. AOL »
February 10, 2006
Vonage Not Far Enough Ahead
The Vonage S-1 finally provided a detailed look at the VOIP leader's financials, which aren't pretty. Given that the company is spending more on marketing than it is generating in revenue, one would hope that at least it would be miles ahead of its dinosaur cable co competition. Alas, it isn't.
According to a table published today in the WSJ, Vonage had 1.2 million subs at the end of 2005, versus 1.1 for Time Warner, 700,000 for Cablevision, and a smattering for other competitors. That Vonage is still No. 1 is good. That it's only No. 1 by the skin of its teeth isn't, especially given that marketing budget.
Time and again in Internet land, nimble upstarts have grabbed the early lead in a product category and, despite the eventual bellowing of incumbent elephants, have managed to hang onto it (Amazon, PayPal, eBay, Google, Yahoo!, AOL, etc.) The difference between each of these cases and Vonage, however, was the size of the lead. After Barnes & Noble finally got around to opening an online store in 1997 (which was widely expected to put Amazon out of business), Amazon continued to grow far more rapidly in the book market and gain even share. Same for all the rest. The early experience of cable companies suggests that there is significant synergy between cable TV, broadband Internet, and VOIP, with customers preferring to purchase VOIP as an add-on service instead of a stand-alone product.
Bottom line, although Vonage certainly grabbed the early mindshare in cable/VOIP, this mindshare did not translate into market share. If a company as lumbering as Time Warner can flick a switch and catch right up, this doesn't bode well for Vonage's competitive position long-term. All is not lost: With its subscriber base and experience in a hot market, Vonage will probably make a nice acquisition, but its days as a stand-alone market leader are probably numbered.
Interestingly, the one VOIP player that does seemed to have translated mindshare into marketshare is Skype. Each day that goes by without a credible competitive product from Yahoo, Microsoft, and AOL--the only companies that have a legitimate shot at derailing Skype--the less likely such a derailment becomes.
Posted by Henry Blodget on February 10, 2006 at 09:56 AM | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83451656f69e200d834a8962469e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Vonage Not Far Enough Ahead:
Comments
The comments to this entry are closed.
Yup- looks like we're looking at a Tivo rather than a Netflix. Which way will SlingMedia go?
Posted by: Aron | February 10, 2006 at 01:40 PM
Good riddance! I tried Vonage for my small business and they were AWFUL.
When I tried to add a fax line they hosed my service and promised
to overnight a new modem. 1 week and no modem later, we called them and
the morons over in their customer service department said they couldn't
do anything and didn't know when the modem would ship. They've soured
me on VOIP for a very very long time. It's error prone and not ready for
prime time.
Posted by: Martin | February 10, 2006 at 06:35 PM
With the new skype phone that creative and netgear are going to produce to skype i dont see any reason why one who already have a broadband will pay $20 a month for calling. Which in skype you could buy something like 15 hours of calling a month. you need at least one teenager in the house for that :)
Posted by: Tel Aviv | March 02, 2006 at 01:52 PM
qjulo hosfarlitn
Posted by: Simon | March 03, 2006 at 10:11 AM
thanks admin good post
Temizlik şirketleri Temizlik şirketleri Sohbet Sohbet odaları
Posted by: ugurss | November 02, 2009 at 06:03 AM