Starters & Salads
Garlic Bread$0.75
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter by the slice.
Cheese Bread$1.35
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter and mozzarella cheese by the slice.
Pagliai’s Bruschetta$1.35
Country Italian bread, sliced thick topped with our own seasoned tomatoes slightly toasted, topped with parmesan cheese by the slice.
Bread Sticks$3.95
Basket of five oven baked bread sticks served with our rich meat sauce.
Tossed Salad$3.75
Mixed greens garnished with red cabbage, carrots, cherry tomato, red onion and croutons with your choice of dressing. (Ranch, French, Italian, and Raspberry Vinaigrette) Additional dressing $1.30.
Greek Salad$7.75
Romaine and mixed greens with Tomato, Feta Cheese, Kalamata olives, red onion, and cucumber with greek dressing.
Chicken BLT Salad$7.75
Romaine and mixed greens with sliced tender chicken breast, tomato, bacon, parmesan and cheddar cheese, cucumber, and red wine vinaigrette.
Chicken Caesar Salad$7.75
Romaine lettuce, sliced tender chicken breast, with shredded parmesan cheese, and croutons all tossed in Caesar Dressing.
Pagliai Calzones
Our own unique twist on an Italian Classic, with crisp dough and a special red sauce. Served with your choice of a side of ranch or marinara.
Classic Zone$8.85
Marinara sauce, sausage, and onion
Chez Zone$8.50
Marinara sauce, provolone cheese, cheddar cheese, and mozzarella cheese.
Meat Zone$9.85
Marinara sauce, beef, sausage, pepperoni, canadian bacon, and mozzarella cheese.
Pesto Zone$8.85
Pesto sauce, pepperoni, onion, pepperoncini, tomato, and mozzarella cheese.
Pag Zone$9.85
Marinara sauce, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, and mozzarella cheese.
Pasta Kitchen
All pasta dinners served with two slices of garlic bread and a tossed salad.
Spaghetti$9.75
Traditional pasta topped with your choice of a rich meat sauce or marinara sauce. Add two meatballs $3.00.
Lasagna$10.75
Layers of pasta with ricotta, mozzarella, and a rich meat sauce.
Fettuccine Alfredo$10.75
Fettuccine noodle with creamy Alfredo. Add chicken or shrimp $3.00.
Cheese Ravioli$10.95
Cheese-stuffed ravioli with your choice of rich meat sauce, pesto or alfredo sauce
Beef Ravioli$10.95
Beef-stuffed ravioli with your choice of rich meat sauce, pesto or alfredo sauce
Pizza
Thin (our specialty) or double (thick & cripsy) crust layered with a specially blended pizza sauce waiting for your choice of our premium toppings.
Each week, a Wisconsin dairy ships an exclusive, custom-made 100% mozzarella cheese to the Pagliai restaurants. This special blend, created according to Pagliai’s specifications and certified by the National Dairy Council, blends skim and whole milks. Preservative-free, lean Italian sausage is ground weekly using small seven-pound preferred cuts of pork roast, a succulent cut regularly chosen by home cooks. Pizza and spaghetti sauces are precise replicas of Mama and Papa Pagliai’s wholesome mixtures of tomatoes, onion, garlic and assorted spices right down to the last dash of oregano. Diners may discover a few other family secrets as they watch their own pizzas being prepared in open, easy-to-view kitchens and slid into stone hearth ovens.
Cheese $8.50 $11.50 $13.50
Gluten-Free Crust $9.95
1 Topping Pizza$9.95 $12.65 $15.45
2 Topping Pizza$11.40 $14.30 $17.40
Additional Toppings or Double Crust $1.45 $1.65 $1.95
Sausage (made in our kitchen), Beef, Pepperoncini, Pepperoni, Tomatoes, Green Olives, Bacon Bits, Artichoke Hearts, Black Olives, Chicken, Onion, Shrimp, Anchovy, Sauerkraut, Fresh Garlic, Pineapple, Green Pepper, Fresh Spinach, Canadian Bacon, Roasted Red Pepper and Fresh Mushrooms
Specialties
No substitutions on Specialties
Pagliai’s Special$11.35 $15.00 $18.00
Sausage, green pepper, onion.
House Special$13.20 $16.50 $20.00
Sausage, beef, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, mushroom.
Taco Pizza$13.20 $16.50 $20.00
Beef, onion, taco chips, sour cream, lettuce, cheddar cheese.
Vegetarian Pizza$12.00 $15.25 $19.00
Marinated spinach, onion, green pepper, mushroom, tomatoes.
Margherita Pesto Pizza$13.20 $16.50 $20.00
Pesto sauce, lite mozzarella, tomatoes, feta cheese, artichokes.
Shrimp Alfredo Pizza$13.20 $16.50 $20.00
Alfredo sauce, shrimp, onion, bacon, three cheeses.
Pepperoni Pesto Pizza$13.20 $16.50 $20.00
Pesto sauce, pepperoni, tomatoes, black olives, onion, feta cheese, pepperoncini.
Sandwich Board
All sandwiches served with Ruffles Potato Chips and pickle spear.
Pag’s Hero$7.50
Cured ham, capocolla, salami, pepperoni and sliced provolone, piled high on a hoagie bun with shredded lettuce and “hero” sauce.
Italian Meatball$7.50
Savory meatballs topped with zesty marinara sauce and provolone cheese on a hoagie bun.
The Grinder$7.50
Italian sausage, onions, roasted peppers and provolone covered with marinara sauce on a hoagie bun.
Italian Steak$7.50
Marinated beef strips with onions, roasted sweet peppers, mushrooms and provolone cheese on a toasted hoagie bun.
Ham & Cheese$7.50
Cured ham with provolone cheese on a hoagie bun.
Beverages
White Wine$5.25
Pinot Grigio, Chardonnay. Price is per glass. Bottles are available for $18.00.
Red Wine$5.25
Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon. Price is per glass. Bottles are available for $18.00.
Sweeter Wines$5.25
White Zinfandel, Chianti. Price is per glass. Bottles are available for $18.00.
Beer On Tap$2.50
Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller Lite, Budweiser and Michelob Amber Bock. Prices are for a pint glass. Pitchers available for $7.25.
Bottles$3.25
Corona, Heineken, Rolling Rock, O’Doul’s, Sam Adams Boston Ale, Bud Select 55, Miller 64, Fat Tire and Blue Moon
Soft Drinks – Endless Glass$1.95
Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mountain Dew, Diet Mountain Dew, Mug Root Beer, Lemonade and Sierra Mist.
Children’s Take Home Cup$1.00
Fresh Brewed Iced Tea$1.95
Hot Tea$1.95
Milk$1.95
2% White or Chocolate. Prices per glass.
Fresh Ground Coffee$1.60
Regular or Decaffeinated.