The Buddhist video game breaks conventions

Posted on by Brian

spacer

In nearly all aspects of our lives, we are taught that success comes through a linear progression. You “level up” in life, career, relationships, physical condition, and in many other ways. This is reinforced through entertainment such as video games, novels, and movies, where someone starts off “weak” and gets stronger as time progresses, challenges are overcome, and goals accomplished. In many cases, there is a final “enemy” to vanquish; an anti-hero.

A recent project from NYU students Bona Kim and James Borda is a video game called “The Buddhist“, and it seeks to challenge the very concept of linear progression by presenting the idea of non-attachment in a medium that is traditionally very linear.

Through “The Buddhist” we hope our audience gains some awakening. By confronting them with a “game” in which any attempt to control the story results in failure, we hope our audience will be brought into the present moment – to enjoy the here and now, free of the anxious search for happiness in some other place and time.

The game was available to play at the ITP Winter Show, NYU’s annual showing of its Interactive Telecommunications Program student projects.

The goal of the game is to observe, reflect, and be in the present moment. Any attempt to control the on-screen character or cause something to happen other than what is currently being displayed on the screen results in “game over”. As you succeed in doing nothing, the on-screen character will go to different environments to meditate. The scenery is pleasing to observe and this is the goal; to observe and enjoy.

Even though it seems silly, it’s a concept that can cause insightful thinking; why do we need to control this character? What kind of feedback are we hoping for by pushing levers and buttons? How is this somehow more appealing than sitting back, observing, and reflecting?

It’s a fascinating art project, and one that causes us to think—by any measure, that’s a success.

This entry was posted in New Buddhists and tagged Art, buddhism, Meditation by Brian. Bookmark the permalink.

25 thoughts on “The Buddhist video game breaks conventions

  1. spacer federica on said:
    At the risk of sounding naive, and of 'not getting it'.... isn't it rather like watching a fly-on-the-wall documentary about a guy practising Buddhism....?
  2. spacer Brian on said:
    No, I think it's nothing like that. When you watch a documentary, passiveness is implied; we do not interact with television.

    Video games are wildly different. The expectation is interaction and control. People's first inclination is to control the character, to win, to accomplish something. Discovering that this causes you to "lose" is the jarring part.
  3. spacer federica on said:
    Oh so you do get buttons and a joystick... and I guess, some kind of interactive dialogue giving you directions, instructions and responses..... I'd love to try it - just to say I've tried it.
    Mind you, with my techno-know-how, I'd probably get the Buddha to bust a blood vessel......
  4. spacer buddhajunkie on said:
    Not sure about the message of this game. "Doing nothing = mindful", "doing something = unmindful". Plenty of people can do nothing unmindfully. And plenty of people can do something and still be mindful. Learning to do the latter is one of the major goals of many modern lay Buddhists. This game seems to reject that endeavor entirely and further reenforces the stereotype that Buddhism and meditation are about being passive and escaping reality.

    Granted, there's minimal information about the story line and game play, so perhaps there's something more to it.
  5. spacer Brian on said:
    Doing nothing isn't the point though. The preexisting convention of "activeness" that is inherent with stepping up to a video game console is the very catalyst behind the thoughtful meditation that almost must ensue after understanding the game. You're forced into insightful meditation by analyzing why you thought you had to "interact". You're not just "standing there, doing nothing" (in my mind, that's what watching TV is), you're actively participating by being insightful while not interacting.
  6. spacer buddhajunkie on said:
    I see. I think a practicing Buddhist could gain a lot from this, as well a player that receives proper instructions on gaining insight (I'm not sure if the game provides instructions on detachment and mindfulness).

    I was just thinking that, for the uninitiated, i.e., if this game were just sitting in an airport somewhere, I think someone would just immediately lose the game and think, "Lame. Good for Buddhists, but I have a job, a family and a mortgage to pay," and walk away without being forced into insight. "Bad mindset in, bad mindset out," seems to be the pattern.

    Have you seen the actual game play? I did a search but I couldn't find anything with more details about it.
  7. spacer Cinorjer on said:
    OK, being a child of the 60s when pacman was invented, I see the challenge. To stand there with buttons and levers in front of me and NOT touch them? Do you know how many hours and quarters I spent learning how to mash and yank on these machines fast as I could? Torture! Pure torture!
  8. spacer Jayantha on said:
    wasnt there just a thread about this a few days back?
  9. spacer Brian on said:
    No. That was a game called Journey that has absolutely nothing to do with this discussion.
  10. spacer Cinorjer on said:
    I will admit though that as described, it doesn't make any sense at all. So you just stand there and watch the screen? Also, "doing nothing at all" is apathy, not being in the present moment. Being present means to respond with a clear mind to the present situation, not passively refuse to engage with life.

    But as an art project, it does sound interesting.
  11. spacer Zero on said:
    It's interesting - I like it - though I think they fell into the duality trap by having 'game over' upon intervention - that said, I can also see that by following the convention, one is met with a conventional response, though in this case it is negative reinforcement only... thought provoking project...
  12. spacer Jayantha on said:
    actually the thread the other day had an article that spoke directly about this "game", but it doesn't matter.

    Now a Buddhist game I'd like to see is one set in the time of the Buddha where you can be a disciple and wander around india listening to dhamma talks by the Buddha and the famous disciples, visiting charnal grounds, meditating in the forest, going on pindapat etc. Kind of like grand theft auto but Buddhist style in ancient India where you can visit all the famous cities, deer parks and locations in the Suttas. You can "pimp out" your robes with different color patches (since the robes back then were sewn together from death rags) and stuff like that. THAT is a game :).
  13. spacer Cinorjer on said:
    Hmm...my own game design, if pressed?

    You start by standing at the door of an old Master's hut, and are asked the question, "Who are you?" and if you correctly answer "I don't know" you're sent on a journey to see various Masters, who ask you questions or give you tasks to perform such as meditate for so long or take a message to the previous Master, and according to how you respond you continue to the next Master. Eventually, you find yourself back at the door you started from, where the same Master asks you the question, "Who are you?"
  14. spacer person on said:
    spacer
  15. spacer Barra on said:
    LOL!
  16. spacer ThailandTom on said:
    Meditation isn't a game man, you can't just like, conceptualize it as a form at attachment in a the some kind of far out game, man :p
  17. spacer Ananda on said:
    This is an interesting concept. Video gaming requires, by its very nature, an attachment to achievement. It is goal-oriented. It is very much the same as life in the sense that you have to keep working at something until you finally succeed and move up to the next level. The challenge always being succeeding until you move up. In some games, when you reach the end, that's it. Nothing else. Fade to black...just like life. Video games, by it's very nature, is very anti-thetical from the concept of meditation. The very idea of simply being mindful without necessarily doing anything would be a challenge for seasoned gamers. For myself, this game wouldn't be much different than being logged in on Second Life and meditating at the virtual temple at the Buddha Center. Sounds like fun :)
  18. spacer lobster on said:
    I was given a gamebox and some games, including 'Grand Theft Auto'. Boring game, you go around, killing and stealing. However I learned a great way of playing it. Basically running and swimming to the countryside. Then enjoying the view. The highlight of the game was when I found a bunch of flowers. In best hippy style I offered them to a police officer, who shot me anyway . . . :)
  19. spacer FLO on said:
    Cinorjer I'll buy your game!
  20. spacer TheBeejAbides on said:
    I play a game called Sound Shapes on the PlayStation 3 console. Its a super fun platformer game that also doubles as a musical creation tool. You are this little ball that rolls around collecting coins that function as music notes, which play in a loop after you collect the coins.

    BUT, the coolest part of the game is that you can create your own levels, and upload them to the server for the entire SoundShapes community to play. You arrange the notes and the 2D platforms, add background decorations, and interactive objects such as creatures and tools. You can manipulate shapes into almost any configuration, and even make highly stylized artistic arrangements/landscapes/portraits/etc. And the game is awesome!

    I just created my first Buddhistish type of level called: "Man Mantra Mandala", where the little ball rolls around a simple but expressive mandala, all the while collecting music notes which create a positive and joyful sound. It is my 34th level that I have created and its one of my favorites. And its been the number one hit in the community for the last week! You can go to soundshapesgame.com to get a better idea of what i am describing if you want to, or buy the game and search for TheBeejAbides, because I use the same username there too. If you grew up with Pitfall, Mario Bros, Sonic the Hedgehog you will certainly love this game. And you can even make your own Mandala type of level if you want to.

    I love the idea of the game that is the topic of this thread. I also love the idea of rolling around inside a mandala. They're both good for Buddhist practice.
    :) :)
  21. spacer julien on said:
    I, as a buddhist and a gamer, really like this concept.

    It does remind me a bit of the game 'endless ocean' for the Nintendo Wii. In this game the player swims around and watches fish and coral and sealife.

    Just being.
    Just floating.
  22. spacer Brian on said:
    Endless Ocean was fantastic.
  23. spacer Amelia on said:
    Beautiful game. Endless Ocean sounds nice too.
  24. spacer 42bodhi on said:
    TheBeejAbides, congrats on your level being number 1!

    I've been told before that meditation on the breath is much like observing wildlife. If you attempt to do anything other than observe, you'll scare the wildlife away.

    It sounds like this game captures that essence of just observing.

    Somebody should definitely get working on a combination of Jayantha's idea and Cinorjer's idea.

    I would also love to see a game based on ancient Buddhist mythology, where one roams around as someone who starts as a god, and then gets thrown about in the in the hell realm, hungry ghost realm, animal realm, human realm, demigod realm, and back to the god realm. The goal of the game is to conquer the difficulties that each realm offers.
  25. spacer Cinorjer on said:
    I play a game called Sound Shapes on the PlayStation 3 console. Its a super fun platformer game that also doubles as a musical creation tool. You are this little ball that rolls around collecting coins that function as music notes, which play in a loop after you collect the coins.

    BUT, the coolest part of the game is that you can create your own levels, and upload them to the server for the entire SoundShapes community to play. You arrange the notes and the 2D platforms, add background decorations, and interactive objects such as creatures and tools. You can manipulate shapes into almost any configuration, and even make highly stylized artistic arrangements/landscapes/portraits/etc. And the game is awesome!

    I just created my first Buddhistish type of level called: "Man Mantra Mandala", where the little ball rolls around a simple but expressive mandala, all the while collecting music notes which create a positive and joyful sound. It is my 34th level that I have created and its one of my favorites. And its been the number one hit in the community for the last week! You can go to soundshapesgame.com to get a better idea of what i am describing if you want to, or buy the game and search for TheBeejAbides, because I use the same username there too. If you grew up with Pitfall, Mario Bros, Sonic the Hedgehog you will certainly love this game. And you can even make your own Mandala type of level if you want to.

    I love the idea of the game that is the topic of this thread. I also love the idea of rolling around inside a mandala. They're both good for Buddhist practice.
    :) :)
    Any chance you can put a capture of that on youtube?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a class="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>