spacer
« Should the Church be Led by Teachers and Scholars?
Sunday Morning Music, Gustav Holst’s The Planets, Jupiter »
08Apr, 2011

The Heart Knows the Truth

spacer I’m working on a friends book at a restaurant down in San Diego, and, even as I type there’s a young woman sitting at the table next to me who is talking to another woman who seems to be her mentor. The younger woman is mentally challenged. She speaks in loud, straight sentences that mostly communicate facts: this coco is hot. This floor is scratched. I like the sunshine.

I’m fascinated, though. I’m loving it, actually. I know I’m wrong to be listening in on somebody else’s conversation, but how can I not? I appreciate the simplicity and even the beauty of her awareness of herself, of what she likes, of what is good, and even of what isn’t. She thinks decaf coffee is dumb. And it is, isn’t it?

What got me, though, was when she started talking about relationships. She told her mentor about a girl who didn’t like her. She said this girl had hurt her feelings. When the mentor asked why, what it was that hurt her feelings, the young woman didn’t accuse the girl of maliciousness or justify her anger or even repeat whatever the comment was that caused the pain. The young woman just told the plain, straight, truth: I want to be her friend but she doesn’t want to be mine. She went on, I’d like her to be my friend. I think I’m a good friend.

Talk about the real language of a real heart. Talk about truth telling. I don’t know where my heart learned to translate it’s sentiments into such false sophistication, but after hearing this conversation, I think false sophistication is akin to lying, and I don’t think lying is the right way to get what you want. I think there’s a good chance this girl is going to get the friendships she wants. Who wouldn’t want to be friends with somebody this honest?

So next time somebody says “why do you not like that that guy?” maybe I’ll be honest and just say “Because I want him to respect me but he doesn’t” or some such truth. I wonder what my world would start to look like if I stopped covering things up with distraction and manipulation and spin?

 

 

 

111 Responses to “The Heart Knows the Truth”

« Older Comments
  1. A Post Worth Reading « A Spot for My Thoughts says:
    April 8, 2011 at 2:36 pm

    [...] Reader recommended this item to me: The Heart Knows the Truth. Read it; you know you want [...]

    Reply
  2. spacer Cara says:
    April 8, 2011 at 3:32 pm

    The interesting thing is that in Christian circles we call this level of honesty immature, and it would be intimated by many Christians that such a person lacks discretion, discernment, emotional maturity, etc. (if in fact they don’t possess a handicap of a type that forces this level of honesty).

    I have long noticed that in many churches, people tapped for leadership positions usually have very high “spin” ability. This doesn’t mean they are liars, but rather that they have learned to put the very best spin on many things and to avoid talking about/calling attention to things they view as less positive or less unifying for a group of people in a religious setting. They excel at putting a glossy face on certain truths and in passing over other truths entirely, and much of the decision-making for how this is done is based on their own personality’s likes and dislikes. This can often lead to an unhealthy environment…

    I have both worked and worshipped in such spin-controlled settings, and ultimately these settings become stultifying and repressive if you are not drinking the Kool-Aid. : )

    Reply
    • spacer Whitney says:
      April 14, 2011 at 4:43 pm

      Amen! I have had the same experience and seen the devastation it wreaks on the follower’s lives. And not just for a day, but leaving them disempowered by spin doctors, and unsure what to trust is true, and how God can meet them in their real situations, and love who they really are.

      Why is this kind of “spin” personality accepted, no loved, in our religious organizations?

      Reply
      • spacer Gaye B. Marston says:
        April 18, 2011 at 9:05 pm

        Try leading a church by being emotionally honest. Not many people (especially church people) truly want to live that way. The risks & consequences are the same as Jesus endured….you look crazy & usually get crucified. We need to be gutsy enough to ask ourselves about our own personal spinning by taking personal inventory & responsibility & by choosing to be that genuine even when you get beaten up for it….anyone up for that?? That’s when it’ll get better.

        Reply
    • spacer sissyfish says:
      April 29, 2011 at 9:51 am

      This comment rings true with me. I am involved in a church that has two groups. The haves and the have nots. Many people have been going to this church all their life. Don’t get me wrong they are a good group of people who do good things. However, do not expect to get a straight answer to any question that you have. Expect to be given very vague answers and often times no answer at all. Do not expect to become part of this group, at least not completely. My business partner made a donation to our church in memory of our son. I told her they would list it in the bulletin and she would receive a thank you note. That’s how that is handled for everyone else. Three months later that still has not been done. I asked our preacher about it. He emailed someone a note about it, who did not answer our question. I have now sent him the second email asking for this to be done again. I am very hurt and upset that her gift was not handled the way all the other gifts have been handled. I’m expected to go quietly into the night over all this. None of it really makes any sense to me. You can imagine how unpopular I am becoming in asking why this was not treated the way everyone else is treated. I’m thinking maybe I’m in the wrong church. Put yourself in my shoes.

      Reply
  3. spacer Beth Craig says:
    April 8, 2011 at 3:53 pm

    Love the authenticity of this post, Don. Keep listening in on conversations. It gives you good material to write to the rest of us!

    Reply
  4. spacer Julie says:
    April 8, 2011 at 4:00 pm

    I wonder if the ‘sophistication’ we should strive for is the ability to speak the unvarnished truth WITH compassion (sound like anyone we know?). But, I don’t think I can do that well until I’m ruthlessly truthful with myself about my own motivations and core feelings. So, what’s my motivation for commenting here?

    Reply
  5. spacer Chandra says:
    April 8, 2011 at 7:50 pm

    Most of the time people who tell it like they see it and speak in clear terms are called mean names or told they lack “tact”. I know because I am such a person and at times yes, I have been tactless in my quest to put it all out there. But, you nail it on the head. It’s a more honest way to way live and I have no real regrets on choosing honesty in relationships over always smoothing things over.

    Looking back on all the problems my “honesty” has caused in relationships, I stand behind how I handled myself in those situations because I was truthful. I think the balance is learning how to do this and not hurt others and also at times accepting that if we sometimes tell the truth, no matter how we do it, we will hurt others.

    Reply
  6. spacer Karen says:
    April 8, 2011 at 7:57 pm

    Truth – in love………….
    I’ve heard that somewhere…..

    Truth and love both important to the author…

    Reply
  7. spacer Lib says:
    April 8, 2011 at 8:03 pm

    I love this post. I love your comment about how we cover up the truth with false sophistication. It doesn’t feel as vulnerable when we use false sophistication–it allows us tip-toe all around the truth of our heart and its desires, without ever really sharing it.

    I went to a women’s bible study for the first time at my church this morning. I went because I really want to meet and connect with women. The study we are doing right now is called “Life Management for Busy Women.” It’s horrible. I don’t think Christ came into our lives to make us more managed. It’s hard to show up real in the church. It’s hard to not speak in false sophistication. In the past I’ve bailed on these types of studies because no one ever shares their heart. But I think I’ll stick around and try to “be the change I want to see.” I will think about this conversation you overheard and try to be real, even if it feels scary.

    Thanks for sharing this.

    Also, on a different note, I just want to tell you I love your writing and your books. You latest book “A Million Miles” really impacted me. My family is in the process of adopting a child now and your book has really helped me push through the fear of it all. Thanks for writing and sharing your story with us.

    Reply
  8. spacer Marci says:
    April 8, 2011 at 9:38 pm

    Thanks Don.

    I yearn for a world that has people who have dropped their masks and who have exposed themselves. And like Gandhi said, “Be the change you want to see in the world”. And that’s where I’ve begun.

    Reply
  9. spacer Christa Knox says:
    April 8, 2011 at 11:14 pm

    I would love to hear such unashamed honesty on a daily basis. What a concept! I know I would probably frighten myself if I broke complicated life pain down to its core principles: I feel hurt, abandoned. But what beauty there would be with the same freeness!

    *Side note: Plain text: ‘I like the music you have recommended. It makes me feel relaxed and happy.’ It makes me picture an open highway in Eastern Oregon. I’ve heard no better road trip soundtrack. I see rolling wheat fields and mountains on the horizon, stretching past the reaches of the widest panoramic lens, bound by all the shades that only the sun wrapping itself in the Pacific can bring.

    Reply
  10. spacer David says:
    April 9, 2011 at 5:25 am

    Fear and impression management too often keep me from being real. Lord, give me courage to be real!

    Reply
    • spacer Lori Ventola says:
      April 9, 2011 at 4:24 pm

      “impression management” — I like that

      Reply
      • spacer Kelly Hessman says:
        April 14, 2011 at 12:43 pm

        Ha that’s great – “impression management” That’s so true…

        Reply
    • spacer Dmarie says:
      May 4, 2011 at 9:51 am

      “impression management”…well said!

      Reply
  11. spacer Helen says:
    April 9, 2011 at 8:19 am

    I love this because the woman is stating the truth as it affects her. She doesn’t judge the other person, she just describes exactly how this person makes her feel. And isn’t that ultimately what happens in relationships–you like or dislike someone, not necessarily because of what they do or say, but based on the way they make you feel.
    Great food for thought.

    Reply
  12. spacer Cindy Garritt says:
    April 9, 2011 at 11:08 am

    I have a son with profound disabilities and a friend who tells me that if I went to the right church or had enough faith or if she introduces me to so and so that he could be healed. But I’m not going there with this thought. My son brings out this honest element in people. I can never guess who may come by to give him a high-five or tell me about their experiences with someone with special needs. In so many ways, Duncan has a much greater impact for Jesus than I will ever have with my masters degree in communication. He makes the jump shot, I take the rebound.

    Reply
  13. spacer Chris Oldcorn says:
    April 9, 2011 at 2:23 pm

    Sometimes we “abled” people just complicate life unnecessarily. This story is a great example of the basics of life.

    Reply
  14. spacer Lori Ventola says:
    April 9, 2011 at 4:39 pm

    I should love this post. And I do love talking with people who are incapable of guile, like this young woman at the restaurant. But this week it makes me really sad, I guess because I long for this kind of communication and feel kinda lost in a world that doesn’t stand for it. We’ll get there, if only in eternity.

    Reply
    • spacer Chris says:
      April 11, 2011 at 10:27 pm

      I feel you, Lori. I’m right there with you :\. It’s like I naturally don’t have the same walls up that everyone else does, and my honesty scares them away.

      Reply
  15. spacer Mike says:
    April 9, 2011 at 8:51 pm

    “Say what you mean, mean what you say.” I recently heard someone preach on that topic and I feel like this is very similar and I’ve noticed me catching myself when I say something just out of habit and I think about it for a second and then I have to say, “I didn’t mean that.” Tough stuff. Or at the least, uncomfortable.

    Reply
  16. spacer Jordan says:
    April 10, 2011 at 12:34 pm

    It seems that one of the great gifts that people with disabilities give us, when we are with them enough to receive, is making us aware of our own disabilities. In this case, the masks we wear and hide behind. I think there is something true about our masks (we are them, in the end), but this still reminds us how much we are playing-posturing-for position.

    Reply
  17. spacer Laurinda Krotish says:
    April 10, 2011 at 1:46 pm

    I agree, sophistication is like overdressing, but I have often been jealous of people who have the wardrobe for it. I haven’t the threads to cloak my honesty. My few friends have seen me naked, and that’s how I know they’re my friends. My would be friends have all run away screaming at the site of my bare bum so no, I don’t think most people want honesty. I think most people prefer metaphors and confusing talk because then they can have different interpretations and everyone’s version of the truth is the right one.

    Reply
  18. spacer Sherri says:
    April 10, 2011 at 9:40 pm

    Beautiful and poetic, I appreciate this. Bob Lenz’ sister, Lois, is amazing like this. I hope you have the chance to meet them someday.

    Reply
  19. spacer RuthintheDesert says:
    April 11, 2011 at 4:50 pm

    Wow. You suddenly have me asking myself I am a good friend. And I am not sure!

    Reply
  20. spacer Jeremy says:
    April 11, 2011 at 8:08 pm

    Hey Donald, would you mind checking this out? If it’s an idea you think is good, and would like to support we’d really appreciate it! Thanks! j.mp/dMP1ar

    Reply
  21. spacer Chris says:
    April 11, 2011 at 10:31 pm

    Beautiful, Don. It’s such a shame that our level of understanding of grace is so shallow that we have to lie to ourselves about who we are. This reminds me a lot of your “Why nudity is the point” chapter in Searching for God Knows What, which has really shaped my view of relationships. Honesty is so vital not just to relationships, but to one’s own sanity. Nobody can stand the charade for very long, but we all put one on to some extent. It’s awesome to see that there are people who live largely outside of that in this fallen world.

    “And they were naked, but they felt no shame.” Such powerful words…can’t wait for heaven spacer

    Reply
  22. spacer Terri S. says:
    April 12, 2011 at 10:45 am

    Once again, great post Don! It’s given me something to chew on for the rest of the week. Very timely. Purity in truth … an interesting concept in this day and age! Thanks brother!

    Reply
  23. spacer kristie vosper says:
    April 12, 2011 at 10:59 am

    Great post. More reasons I love hanging out with kids…but even they learn to spin their story quickly.

    Reply
  24. False Sophistication « squeeze it into little inkdrops says:
    April 13, 2011 at 6:34 pm

    [...] Miller.  You can tell my favorite point he makes by the title I chose.  You can either go to the link, or read it [...]

    Reply
  25. spacer Bethany says:
    April 13, 2011 at 8:07 pm

    It is brave work to connect to self with curiosity and to then live boldly out of what we learn. Our shame and fear can so quickly turn us toward self-contempt or contempt toward others. To remain connected to both pain and desire with kindness can be a slow but redemptive and freeing process.

    Reply
  26. spacer brie. says:
    April 14, 2011 at 5:16 am

    such honesty is so rare and thus, so difficult for us to process, i think. we cover up how we feel with fancy language and distraction because it would take so much honesty it almost make the hurt more real…and yet it sounds incredibly freeing to live in the rawness of it all…thanks.

    Reply
  27. Simple Follower of Jesus » Blog Archive » The Power of a Story says:
    April 14, 2011 at 1:34 pm

    [...] an example of a brief, well-told story, you might enjoy this short piece about a conversation between two ladies Donald Miller overheard at a restaurant.  I enjoyed [...]

    Reply
    • spacer nick says:
      April 14, 2011 at 3:07 pm

      thanks Donald for sharing.

      i’ve been following your blog for awhile and often gain inspiration from something you share. i’ve yet to read any of your books, but blue like jazz is on my list.

      recently i’ve been thinking about “story” and this post of yours tied in well, so i referenced it.

      p.s. if you commented on my blog, i would feel famous spacer

      Reply
  28. spacer Jsdavies says:
    April 14, 2011 at 2:28 pm

    Overall, I think the major failure of communication relates to these c

gipoco.com is neither affiliated with the authors of this page nor responsible for its contents. This is a safe-cache copy of the original web site.