Accuracy Scores

Who Gives the Best Fantasy Football Advice?
  • 2011
  • 2010
  • 2009
  • 2010 Draft
  • 2011 IDP
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2011 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

Read our summary | View weekly results
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Scott Pianowski - Yahoo63.7%64.1%61.6%69.4%60.4%56.6%56.8%
2John Paulsen - The Fantasy Shrink63.7%62.9%62.3%69.1%63.1%52.6%53.4%
3Kevin Hanson - EDSFootball63.5%63.4%62.3%70.3%58.0%51.3%51.1%
4Josh Moore - 4for4.com63.5%63.5%62.1%68.7%60.3%N/AN/A
5Sablich Brothers - The New York Times63.3%63.8%61.5%67.3%61.5%55.3%56.5%
6Jeff Ratcliffe - Pro Football Focus63.2%62.7%62.0%69.6%59.8%54.1%53.2%
7Staff Composite - Yahoo63.1%62.5%61.3%68.3%62.9%56.0%57.2%
8Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld63.1%61.9%61.8%68.6%62.9%56.3%55.0%
9Mike Woellert - FantasyFootball.com62.9%62.1%63.1%67.1%59.6%50.3%50.7%
10Site Rankings - FantasyFootballNerd62.9%62.5%62.8%66.5%59.5%51.4%52.7%
11Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly62.9%63.6%59.6%68.0%63.0%56.4%58.3%
12Staff Composite - ESPN62.8%63.2%61.8%68.4%56.8%52.2%52.2%
13Ken Zalis - Fans Fantasy Football62.8%62.7%61.5%68.3%59.5%54.2%55.3%
14Ken Moody - Dynasty League Football62.7%62.0%61.7%68.8%59.9%N/AN/A
15Michael Fabiano - NFL.com62.7%62.4%62.0%66.6%60.1%58.4%48.6%
16Russ Bliss - Fantasy Football Starters62.7%63.7%60.9%66.0%59.7%54.2%52.6%
17Chet Gresham - Razzball62.6%62.3%62.0%66.3%60.4%56.1%53.0%
18Site Projections - numberFire62.6%62.8%60.6%67.9%60.4%52.5%55.3%
19Staff Rankings - FFToolbox62.5%62.6%60.3%68.2%60.8%50.9%55.3%
20Tristan Cockcroft - ESPN62.5%61.7%62.1%69.1%56.8%55.5%49.0%
21Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys62.4%63.4%59.5%65.4%63.2%N/AN/A
22Walter Cherepinsky - Walter Football62.4%61.8%60.7%66.4%64.2%55.5%N/A
23Christopher Harris - ESPN62.4%61.9%61.4%68.4%58.2%51.8%52.6%
24Derek Lofland - FFManiaxs62.3%63.2%61.5%63.9%59.4%N/AN/A
25Staff Composite - NFL.com62.3%62.0%61.4%66.8%59.6%52.8%48.8%
26Andy Behrens - Yahoo62.3%60.9%61.1%68.0%62.4%54.5%57.6%
27Staff Rankings - Chinstrap Ninjas 62.2%62.1%61.8%67.5%56.2%51.2%52.3%
28Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe62.2%61.8%61.0%68.2%58.6%50.4%54.1%
29Staff Composite - SI.com62.2%61.8%60.1%68.8%59.8%52.9%55.8%
30David Dodds - FootballGuys62.1%63.2%59.5%66.0%60.6%45.8%50.7%
31Staff Rankings - Fantasy Football Freaks62.0%62.6%62.2%67.4%51.8%39.4%46.4%
32Site Projections - CBS Sports62.0%63.2%59.7%67.9%56.5%54.1%54.4%
33Brad Evans - Yahoo62.0%62.6%60.6%65.2%59.4%52.3%55.8%
34Eric Karabell - ESPN61.9%61.9%61.6%66.3%56.6%51.7%50.2%
35Adam Rank - NFL.com61.7%61.3%60.6%67.6%57.9%50.9%51.1%
36Mike Clay - Pro Football Focus61.6%62.5%60.0%63.0%61.5%53.5%54.2%
37Alessandro Miglio - Pro Football Focus61.4%60.3%60.4%67.5%59.5%53.0%46.2%
38Matthew Berry - ESPN61.4%61.7%60.1%66.8%56.7%51.5%51.2%
39Dave Dameshek - NFL.com61.4%61.7%60.4%64.1%59.1%56.9%48.3%
40Brandon Funston - Yahoo61.4%61.0%61.2%65.5%57.3%53.6%56.4%
41Dave Richard - CBS Sports61.4%64.2%59.1%64.8%53.6%51.7%49.4%
42Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports61.2%63.2%58.4%67.5%54.1%54.5%53.3%
43Matt Smith - NFL.com61.2%60.5%61.3%64.9%58.3%51.5%48.2%
44Mike Krueger - FFToday61.2%62.4%59.2%65.0%57.5%60.0%51.3%
45Eric Mack - SI.com60.8%59.7%58.8%67.6%61.0%56.4%55.3%
46Kevin Roberts - NFL Soup60.8%58.9%60.6%69.5%56.2%50.0%54.9%
47Ryan Lester - Lester's Legends60.7%59.6%61.0%65.4%57.2%53.3%48.2%
48Paul Greco - FantasyPros91160.7%63.2%57.5%63.4%57.6%48.0%52.2%
49Michael Beller - SI.com60.7%58.3%61.6%66.2%58.5%58.5%47.0%
50Patrick White - Fantasy Sharks60.7%61.1%58.3%65.0%59.8%50.6%51.8%
51Robb Perkins - Fantasy Football Trader60.7%60.9%59.5%63.1%59.7%54.0%49.6%
52Jason Sarney - Fantasy Phenoms60.6%60.4%58.7%67.6%57.0%26.2%42.6%
53Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports60.6%59.8%58.3%67.4%60.3%50.4%45.5%
54Keet Bailey - NFL Soup60.5%60.0%61.6%64.5%53.5%53.2%51.0%
55Site Projections - scoutPRO60.3%58.8%59.1%66.2%60.5%47.5%55.3%
56Staff Rankings - Fantazzle60.0%60.4%58.4%64.4%57.4%49.8%51.8%
57Dan McQuade - SI.com60.0%59.3%58.8%66.9%56.1%46.3%56.8%
58Anthony Perri - Insider Football59.7%59.7%59.7%61.1%58.0%52.5%43.2%
59Site Projections - AccuScore59.7%58.1%60.8%65.1%54.3%54.1%53.0%
60David Sabino - SI.com58.9%59.3%57.8%62.9%54.7%48.1%48.4%
61Site Projections - ESPN58.5%58.7%59.9%62.7%48.0%N/AN/A
62Site Projections - FFToday57.9%61.1%53.9%60.8%54.1%N/A52.0%
63Staff Rankings - KFFL57.2%58.8%55.1%58.1%56.7%50.0%43.5%
64Staff Projections - FantasySharks56.2%60.8%51.9%59.0%49.5%59.6%50.5%
65Site Projections - SI.com55.6%58.2%52.4%58.5%52.2%43.8%51.8%
66Staff Projections - WhatIfSports55.1%56.9%56.8%52.7%47.6%50.9%46.5%
67Smitty - Fantasy Football Xtreme54.6%55.8%54.8%56.9%46.5%N/AN/A
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2010 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

Over one million predictions scored (view our summary)
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1John Paulsen - The Fantasy Shrink61.3%62.8%59.3%62.2%60.8%60.0%N/A
2David Dodds - FootballGuys60.4%63.3%57.4%63.4%55.8%51.7%54.7%
3Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.2%61.6%58.5%63.3%56.1%59.4%46.2%
4Josh Moore - 4for4.com59.9%61.2%58.7%62.0%55.7%N/AN/A
5Site Rankings - FantasyFootballNerd59.8%63.0%55.6%62.8%57.7%56.7%50.3%
6Chet Gresham - Razzball59.7%61.4%57.8%61.0%58.2%54.2%48.7%
7Staff Composite - ESPN59.6%60.6%57.9%60.9%59.4%53.9%44.3%
8Staff Composite - Yahoo59.5%61.5%57.6%61.7%54.9%61.4%46.1%
9Site Projections - Yahoo59.4%60.0%57.2%66.7%53.3%N/AN/A
10Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld59.2%60.5%58.2%60.3%56.0%54.8%48.2%
11Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly59.1%59.3%57.8%62.4%58.4%53.9%51.8%
12Scott Pianowski - Yahoo59.1%60.5%57.4%62.4%54.8%60.8%53.6%
13Erik Kuselias - ESPN59.1%59.5%57.6%63.5%56.3%54.8%44.7%
14Site Rankings - Ultimate FF Strategy59.0%61.9%58.0%58.5%53.2%55.0%49.4%
15Eric Karabell - ESPN59.0%60.0%57.6%58.9%60.2%50.0%43.0%
16Site Projections - CBS Sports59.0%60.9%56.8%63.8%52.2%N/AN/A
17Ryan Lester - Lester's Legends58.8%60.8%56.1%60.4%58.0%57.2%43.7%
18Staff Rankings - Fantazzle58.7%59.1%57.9%61.8%55.6%51.6%46.4%
19Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys58.6%59.9%55.8%63.8%55.2%N/AN/A
20Kevin Roberts - NFL Soup58.5%58.3%59.1%60.0%55.5%55.2%47.3%
21Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports58.4%59.1%57.2%60.8%56.5%52.3%46.5%
22Matthew Berry - ESPN58.4%59.7%56.2%59.4%59.0%56.5%43.6%
23Christopher Harris - ESPN58.3%58.8%57.5%59.5%56.9%51.9%44.8%
24Staff Rankings - FFToolbox58.3%59.8%56.5%61.7%53.7%52.6%47.8%
25Brandon Funston - Yahoo58.1%60.2%56.9%57.3%55.8%56.8%43.8%
26Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe57.5%58.5%56.2%60.4%53.9%50.4%49.0%
27Brad Evans - Yahoo57.3%60.2%55.2%59.0%51.2%58.4%46.6%
28Sexy Rexy - Game of Inches57.3%57.6%56.6%59.9%54.5%N/AN/A
29Dave Richard - CBS Sports56.9%59.7%54.3%61.6%48.8%52.9%46.9%
30Walter Cherepinsky - Walter Football56.8%57.2%57.3%57.2%53.2%50.1%N/A
31Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports56.6%56.1%55.1%59.6%58.5%51.4%47.1%
32Staff Rankings - KFFL56.6%57.9%56.0%57.4%52.5%48.0%48.7%
33Site Rankings - FanHouse56.5%57.8%53.9%60.7%53.7%54.4%45.8%
34Brad Richter - RotoPilot56.1%60.3%54.0%53.8%51.3%49.4%43.6%
35Site Projections - ESPN55.5%58.6%51.2%54.7%59.9%N/AN/A
36Mike Krueger - FFToday55.0%56.6%53.9%54.3%54.4%55.8%47.4%
37Staff Projections - WhatIfSports53.5%55.6%52.4%52.7%50.9%57.1%46.3%
38Site Projections - SI.com52.4%55.0%51.4%50.9%49.3%55.5%46.3%
39Staff Projections - FantasySharks52.1%56.5%51.5%50.5%41.2%48.7%52.3%
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2009 Accuracy (Weeks 1-16)

View our summary of these results
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.8%62.5%59.7%60.3%58.7%57.9%55.0%
2Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly60.7%63.4%60.2%58.3%57.5%54.4%61.2%
3Brandon Funston - Yahoo60.4%61.4%60.6%60.9%56.2%60.5%57.7%
4Gregg Rosenthal - Rotoworld60.3%60.0%60.3%60.0%61.2%54.7%54.7%
5David Dodds - FootballGuys60.2%65.2%58.0%57.3%54.6%49.1%61.1%
6Scott Pianowski - Yahoo60.0%61.4%59.1%60.2%58.1%59.8%61.1%
7Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys59.9%64.9%58.5%56.0%52.9%N/AN/A
8Staff Composite - FantasyFootball.com59.5%61.4%58.2%58.7%58.1%49.7%60.4%
9Brad Evans - Yahoo59.2%61.5%57.6%57.1%59.2%59.0%55.3%
10R.J. White - FFCafe59.2%63.6%56.0%55.9%58.1%55.5%55.7%
11Erik Kuselias - ESPN58.9%62.6%58.1%56.7%52.2%57.8%58.2%
12Staff Rankings - FantasyFootballCafe58.8%60.9%57.0%58.1%58.2%47.3%57.1%
13Scott Engel - RotoExperts58.7%61.4%57.9%53.5%59.5%N/AN/A
14Eric Karabell - ESPN58.5%60.2%56.5%57.6%59.9%55.4%53.5%
15Christopher Harris - ESPN58.4%59.3%59.0%56.3%56.6%48.9%54.3%
16Staff Rankings - FFToolbox58.4%61.7%53.7%58.0%61.1%N/A60.9%
17Matthew Berry - ESPN58.1%61.7%56.4%56.2%53.6%58.8%52.8%
18Site Projections - CBS Sports53.7%58.5%50.7%51.3%49.9%55.4%51.9%
19Site Projections - SI.com53.7%55.00%54.6%46.5%56.9%53.1%56.5%
20Staff Rankings - KFFL53.5%57.9%53.4%49.9%47.9%50.7%49.4%
21Paul Greco - FantasyPros91153.1%55.6%49.5%53.3%54.5%55.1%52.3%
PAY™ | Prediction Accuracy Yield

2010 Draft Accuracy

Based on preseason player rankings (view our summary)
RankExpert NameOverall*RBWRQBTEDSTK
1Jamey Eisenberg - CBS Sports64.4%56.5%64.9%84.3%61.8%61.0%35.0%
2David Dodds - FootballGuys63.6%55.4%78.7%63.0%61.9%52.6%31.7%
3Pat Fitzmaurice - ProFootballWeekly62.6%57.3%63.1%75.9%59.9%58.9%N/A
4Bob Henry - FootballGuys62.2%52.9%71.1%71.4%63.9%49.4%20.2%
5Jeff Pasquino - FootballGuys61.7%57.0%67.9%55.8%80.7%58.0%42.2%
6Michael Fabiano - NFL.com61.5%61.2%59.7%61.9%67.9%N/AN/A
760.8%53.1%66.9%72.9%56.9%64.7%41.7%
8Christopher Harris - ESPN60.6%58.0%56.4%69.6%68.2%N/AN/A
9Staff Rankings - FFToolbox60.4%51.8%68.4%75.2%48.6%58.3%N/A
10Andy Behrens - Yahoo60.1%60.6%61.8%68.2%33.4%36.5%38.8%
11Staff Composite - Yahoo59.0%62.2%52.9%62.1%54.1%N/AN/A
12Paul Greco - FantasyPros91158.6%46.8%70.5%62.6%76.7%62.6%28.2%
13Sigmund Bloom - FootballGuys58.3%50.8%66.6%60.6%68.0%N/AN/A
14Anthony Borbely - FootballGuys58.0%49.1%72.0%50.9%77.7%49.0%34.6%
15Jason Wood - FootballGuys57.4%49.2%67.2%64.8%54.1%64.3%33.9%
16Brandon Funston - Yahoo57.2%54.6%61.7%59.4%52.0%30.4%46.1%
17Scott Pianowski - Yahoo57.0%55.1%62.6%57.7%47.8%32.7%37.0%
18Andrew Garda - FootballGuys56.7%46.6%61.6%66.9%74.7%N/AN/A
19Staff Composite - ESPN56.7%50.7%56.2%68.7%64.6%N/AN/A
20Mike Krueger - FFToday56.6%51.2%60.1%63.9%58.5%53.8%25.1%
21Clayton Gray - FootballGuys55.3%40.4%62.1%73.8%74.4%49.7%40.2%
22Brad Evans - Yahoo55.2%61.3%65.3%33.4%37.3%44.4%35.7%
23Jene Bramel - FootballGuys55.2%46.4%66.3%53.1%72.2%N/AN/A
24Andy Hicks - FootballGuys54.5%51.5%54.7%55.9%67.1%N/AN/A
25Staff Projections - FantasySharks54.1%46.1%49.5%76.2%63.9%62.6%38.8%
26John Norton - FootballGuys53.4%43.6%57.7%66.5%65.1%39.5%45.0%
27Maurile Tremblay - FootballGuys52.9%51.6%58.0%58.1%31.5%31.4%40.0%
28Eric Karabell - ESPN52.8%50.0%51.8%63.4%48.1%N/AN/A
29Roger Rotter - Roger Rotter Sports52.7%42.0%52.1%73.0%68.8%72.9%21.5%
30Jeff Haseley - FootballGuys52.6%51.1%52.1%57.1%52.3%50.3%32.0%
31Matthew Berry - ESPN52.2%49.4%46.0%66.0%57.0%N/AN/A
32Dave Richard - CBS Sports51.9%39.0%54.1%74.2%66.0%68.2%37.6%
33Jeff Tefertiller - FootballGuys45.5%42.6%47.2%44.0%59.5%43.3%N/A
34Mark Wimer - FootballGuys45.4%29.2%57.6%62.1%58.7%45.5%38.8%

* Overall PAY is a weighted average of QB, RB, WR and TE (DST and K scores are not included). The weights are determined by the relative importance of each position.

spacer View Accuracy FAQ
gipoco.com is neither affiliated with the authors of this page nor responsible for its contents. This is a safe-cache copy of the original web site.