 |
|
|
Introduction Ahhh....tires! Tires, tires, tires! Is there any other component on your rig that elicits such an emotional response, such heated debate, such pride, as its tires? Pull up to a trail ride or event and what's the first thing you notice about the other guys' or gals' rigs? Watch closely and what's the first thing they stroll over and look at on yours? It's not the motor or the gearing or the suspension...it's the tires. And for good reason...whether street-driven or trailered, buggy on 42's or Jeep on 31's - your tires say a lot about your rig. Whether in mud, snow, or rocks, tires can make or break your rigs performance so it's obviously pretty important to choose the right tires. The ironic thing is, unlike many other components, there's precious little hard data available to compare tires. With engines, axles, and suspension we can talk of horsepower, torque load capability, anti-squat, valving, and spring rates. With tires we're much more reliant on experience, word-of-mouth, gut feel, and reputation. To complicate matters, in the past several years there has been a marked increase in the number and different types of tires available for your hardcore 4x4. There are old players with new offerings, there are narrow-focus competition tires, there are even new companies more traditionally associated with sports cars selling offroad tires. And with pro competition, sponsorships, marketing deals, advertising, and the Internet full of "experts" it can all get pretty confusing pretty fast. With this article I aim to give you some ideas to help you decide where to spend your tire dollars. It used to be the off-road crowd were divided into two camps - those that had Super Swampers - and those that wanted them. In essence, the "Swamper" was King. So now I'm going to answer the question: "For an all-round, hardcore, off-road tire - is the Swamper still King? " Before I go any further, I should point out that this article is aimed at the hard core enthusiast. It's for the individual who places a premium on off road performance - above all else. Whether street driven or trailered; Suzuki, Ford of buggy - it's about serious off-road ability and not about quiet ride, mileage, or tread-wear warranties. Basic Tire Tech Before I get into the why's and wherefore's of my favorite tires we should first go over a little basic tire tech. Not only because, as usual, we need to be sure we're talking about the same things, but also because knowing precisely what a tire is made of, how it's made, how it works, and what the differences are between types has a surprisingly large effect on how we view our tires - and ultimately what we decide to buy. I know, I know, you're thinking, "What's to know - it's a tire for God's sake - surely even BillaVista couldn't over-complicate it!" And you'd be wrong ;-) What is a tire and what does it do? On the face of it, this bit's actually quite simple. A tire is just a rubber air bladder that contains pressurized air to support the vehicle's weight, right? Well, yes...but it also transmits acceleration, braking, and cornering forces to the road or trail, and acts as a spring between the trail and the wheel. It's able to do all this because of the way it's constructed. You see, a tire isn't just a rubber balloon - it has a carcass made of plies (or layers) that give it shape, strength, and stability (otherwise when filled with air it would just expand in a wobbly and useless round fashion like a balloon tire in a kids picture). It has a steel bead to clamp it to the rim with sufficient friction to transmit acceleration and braking from the rim to the trail and vice versa. It has tread blocks to grip the road and trail, tread voids to shed mud, snow and water, and it can have cap-plies or steel belts under the tread to stabilize the tread and reduce punctures. The plies themselves are made of chords of fibrous material (polyester, fiberglass, nylon, rayon, steel mesh, kevlar, etc.) woven together and coated with rubber. It is the plies in a tire that give the tire shape and strength and prevent it from expanding like a balloon, thus allowing the build up of load supporting pressure. What are the parts?
The major parts of a tire are as follows: Body: The body, also known as the carcass or casing, is the core of the tire. Made up of body plies, it is beneath the tread and inside the sidewalls. Chords: Lengths of fibrous material (polyester, kevlar, nylon, etc.) that lie at the heart of a ply. Ply: A fibrous, fabric layer made from chords woven together and coated with rubber.
Bead: High-strength, rubber-coated, steel cable that clamps the tire to the rim. Tread: A compound of many natural and synthetic rubbers and other components that contacts the road.
Sidewall: The rubber between the tread and the bead, it provides lateral stability for the tire and protects the body plies. Shoulder: The area where the tread and sidewall meet. Inner liner: The innermost rubber layer in a tubeless tire that helps to make it air-tight. Steel Belts: Belts of steel mesh that lie under the tread to provide puncture resistance and keep the tread area flat for maximum road grip. Edge Cover: Optional special circumferential reinforcements above the steel belts found in high-speed tires. Also called belt edge strips. Essentially, a tire is made as follows: - The beads are formed from steel
cable Dimensions To have a meaningful discussion about tires, in addition to knowing the names of all these parts, there are some important dimensions of a tire that we must know. These are illustrated and described below:
Overall * Since a tire's section width
and diameter changes depending on the width of the rim on which it is mounted
(the tire gets wider and taller if mounted on a wide rim, and narrower and shorter
if mounted on a narrow rim), each tire is measured on a specific rim width,
called the "design rim". For tires with aspect ratios between 50 and
80, the design rim width is usually 70% of the tire's section width. For tires
with an aspect ratio less than 50, the design rim's width is normally 85% of
the tire's section width. Aspect Ratio = Section Height divided by Section Width Aspect Ratio is the relationship of a tire's height to width when mounted and inflated on a rim of correct size. Aspect ratios are expressed as a two digit percentage such as 80, 70, 60 etc. This number, as a percentage, means the height of the tire's sidewall (its Section Height) is x% of its width. Aspect ratios are also often referred to as the tire's 'series'. For example, if section height/section width is 0.60 (60%), the tire is a 60 series tire. Why do we care about a tire's Aspect Ratio? Because the height to width relationship determines the shape of the tire on the rim, and, more importantly, determines the performance characteristics of the tire. If the sidewall height of a tire is reduced slightly, the sidewall stiffness is increased greatly. Higher Aspect Ratios deliver greater deflection under load and a softer ride. Lower aspect ratios deliver a wider footprint, quicker response, less slip angle, lower flex rate, less deflection and a harsher ride. Also, typically, a high aspect ratio tire will have a long, narrow footprint, while a low aspect ratio will have a short, wide footprint. At least that's all true in the street-car world. Things are a little different for us because the amount by which we air down our tires overdides the Aspect Ratio in determining the tire's footprint and responsiveness. Construction - Radial, Bias Ply, and Bias Belted
There are 3 basic types of tires, named for the 3 main ways of constructing a tire, differentiated by the way the body plies are oriented. They are:
Bias Ply The body plies in a bias ply tire are laid down at an angle (or bias) to the centerline of the tread, and are stacked one upon the other in a multi-layer criss-cross fashion. These criss-crossing layers are generally oriented 32 to 40 degrees from the centerline of the tread. Since the chords that make up the plies are fibers, they are strong in tension but have no strength in compression. This is why the plies are laid down at a bias and on top of one another - to give the tire its strength in both directions - and is also why there are always an even number of body plies in a bias ply tire. The body plies are frequently made of nylon chords but other materials can be used. Nylon is very strong but is also very stiff. These stiff, strong layers must essentially scissor against each other as the tires flexes which builds heat, causing the tire to run hotter than a radial. Over time, heat degrades a tire. That said - this building of heat is really only an issue in sustained road driving at speed. Bias ply tires also do not have cap plies or steel belts under the tread - as a result, when the tire is loaded by the vehicle the chords are stretched and the entire body supports the weight. Since there are no other layers under the tread, the tread tends to be slightly rounded, creating a smaller contact patch (relative to a same-size radial) that reduces road handling. Because of our practice of airing down this reduced contact patch is of no concern off-road. On the other hand, since bias body plies run from bead to bead there is no transition from a circumferential belt to sidewall - the tread and sidewall construction are the same. As a result, tread can be wrapped around and down the sidewalls of a bias ply tire for extra traction and protection - the perfect example of which is the TSL/SX - a tire not offered in radial design.
The overlapping, criss-cross plies of a bias ply tire results in a carcass and sidewall that are thick, stiff, and strong. This very strong sidewall more easily withstands trail hazards and punctures than a radial design (where all the chords run in the same direction, are generally made of weaker, more flexible polyester, and there are fewer plies). This is not only because the multiple plies result in a great thickness (making it harder to penetrate completely), but also because of the alternating angles of the bias ply. If an injury does occur in the sidewall of a bias ply tire it is much less likely to completely rip or tear (called a "zipper") than radial tire. Imagine it like this: take 2 wooden boards and glue/bond them together with the grains running in the same direction. Now strike the top edge with an axe - they will split readily....the zipper! Now, bond the same two boards together again, but this time lay one on top of the other at an angle (a bias) of 30-40 degrees. They will now resist splitting completely when struck with the axe - just like the overlapping body plies in a bias ply tire (when abused offroad - not hit with an axe, of course!) A bias ply tire can be aired down lower than an equivalent radial tire. This is because the heavy-duty sidewalls of a bias ply tire also help support the load more than in a radial. Remember that the plies criss-cross across a bias ply tire. One layer is strong in the weak direction of another. As the tire is compressed and flattened by the load, some of the cords are put under tension where the great tensile strength of nylon results in the sidewall supporting the load in conjunction with the air pressure inside the tire - the result being we need less air pressure in the tire to support the load. Bias ply construction also presents two additional characteristics - neither of which are of any real concern in a hardcore trail rig. Due to their weight and lack of steel belts or cap plies, bias ply tires tend to be less fuel efficient for highway use than radial tires. Also, nylon has a tendency to take a set when statically loaded, especially when cold, resulting in the "square tire" syndrome. Radial There are two main differences in the construction of radial tires compared to bias ply tires that account for their dramatically different on and off-road performance characteristics: the orientation of the body plies and the addition of steel belts and/or cap plies under the tread. In a radial tire the body plies are laid down perpendicular to the center line of the tread - they appear to radiate from the center line - hence the name "radial". There are also usually many fewer body plies than in a bias ply design - up to a maximum of 3 compared to the up to 16 used in a bias ply tire. In fact, a radial tire needs only one body ply, and thus is not only less stiff, but runs much cooler, and weighs less. If more than one body ply is used , successive body plies are layered over the existing ones with all the chords being parallel. In addition, the body plie(s) of a radial tire are generally made of polyester which is softer and not as tough or strong as the nylon common in bias ply tires. Radial tires also use a wide variety of cap plies and/or steel belts under the tread. These belts are placed in successive layers circumferentially around the casing, under the tread. They are independent from the body plies, are made from a variety of materials (including steel, fiberglass, and nylon) that are different from the materials used in the body plies, and so cause a discontinuity where the sidewall and tread meet. Each belt adds an additional layer in the tread area but leaves the sidewall area untouched. This belted radial design, this discontinuity between sidewall and tread, results in the tread being independent from the sidewall - the steel belts provide a stable foundation for the tread allowing the sidewall to be more flexible. In a radial tire sidewall flexing does not alter tread pattern. As the tire flattens out under loads or impact, the sidewall plies just bend, adding very little resistance. The following diagrams illustrate the difference between bias ply and radial tires in terms of the effect of sidewall flexing on tread stability and contact patch.
The combination of the radial pattern, softer polyester material, and use of belts (independent tread and sidewall) gives a radial tire more sidewall flex which allows the tire to absorb road shock and noise thus producing a much smoother ride. The softer polyester chords also resist flat-spotting much better than the stiff nylon chords in a bias ply - especially in the cold. On-road it also results in the load being distributed equally across the contact area as well as better traction with less heat build up resulting in longer life and improved fuel economy. By restricting tread movement during contact with the road, the belt plies improve tread life. In addition steel belts protect the casing under the tread against high-speed impacts and punctures. However, the sidewall is generally weaker on radial tires than on bias tires when it comes to puncture and damage resistance. Part of this is due to fewer body plies and less rubber being used, and part is due to the fact that, in a radial tire, even a small injury can lead to massive tear because the body plies have all their chords running parallel to one another. Also, since the radial sidewall adds very little stiffness (indeed is designed to be much more flexible), as can be seen in the distinctive radial tire "bulge", the load is almost entirely carried by the air and thus radial tires cannot be aired down as low as bias ply tires carrying the same load. In addition, the discontinuity between tread and sidewall in a radial tire is the reason radial tires don't have substantial sidewall tread. Because the radial design depends on thin, flexible sidewalls it defeats the purpose to add significant rubber tread to the sidewall, and doing so would cause a lot of heat buildup from radial sidewall flexing. In any case, even if some form of tread is added to the sidewall of a radial their will still be a break in the transition from tread to sidewall. Other components found in a radial tire but not in a bias ply are bead chaffers and cap plies - usually built into performance tires to enhance cornering and stability at high speeds. Bias Belted Bias belted tires are a hybrid combination that have criss-cross bias body plies like a bias ply tire, combined with cap plies / steel belts like a radial tire. Frequently the belts and body plies are made from different materials. For example, a polyglass tire may have polyester plies and fiberglass belts. Bias belted tires have a wider tread area than the bias ply - providing better traction and stopping power. They also have more flexible sidewalls than the bias ply, resulting in less internal heat buildup during driving and consequently greater tread life. On the surface they may seem like an ideal compromise - a way to combine the benefits of both radial and bias ply design. However, they of course also combine the weaknesses of both designs. I believe this is the reason they have never really caught on and are all but nonexistent in the market place - very few bias belted tires are manufactured today. This is probably due to the fact that both bias ply and radial tires fit their niche, accomplish their goals, so well that the potential consumer of either is not willing to compromise either with a hybrid tire. Those seeking tough, durable off-road tires with maximum sidewall strength and tread will choose bias ply tires - those seeking on-road performance, tread-life, and handling will choose radial tires. Which One to Choose? Virtually all street/car tires sold are radials due to their superior handling, ride quality, and wear. Radial construction allows the tire to better flex and absorb the irregularities of the road surface. The radial design also produces much less friction resulting in cooler running tires and much longer tread life. But bias ply tires refuse to disappear from the market. The overlapping, criss-cross reinforcement design of bias ply tires makes them very durable. Since the sidewall is as strong as the rest of the body, it can withstand lateral loads, twisting, and bending which would cause a radial to split - especially in an aired-down tire. This strength and durability of the bias ply construction is also a benefit in high torque conditions like when a spinning tire suddenly gets traction. Also because of the one-piece tread/sidewall design, much more aggressive and functional tread can be added to the sidewall of a bias ply tire. The following diagram and table summarize the strengths and weaknesses of radial and bias ply construction:
Summary Bias ply tires are the clear choice for serious off-roading because of their sidewall strength, aggressive tread, and ability to be run at low single-digit pressures. For serious, hardcore trail riding, the strength and durability of the bias ply trumps all - after all, when you're wheeling brutal terrain miles from nowhere the best tire is the one that still holds air! Radials are the best choice for on-road driving because of their softer ride, improved handling, and longer tread life. If you drive both on- and off-road you have to decide which is more important - the road manners of the radial or the toughness of the bias ply. Me - I'll compromise road manners for trail performance every time. If you're compromising, whichever you choose, there are a couple of precautions to note: - When running a bias ply tire on the street, strict attention must be paid to tire pressures. The stiff sidewalls can easily disguise an under-inflated tire. Street driving even slightly under-inflated bias ply tires can be hazardous because the scissoring body plies already build a lot of heat - this is exacerbated by under-inflation to the point that the tires can quickly build enough heat to cause ply separation and catastrophic tire failure. - Radials tires, of course, also need correct air pressure on the street. Excessive heat in a radial tire leads to sidewall cracking, zipper blowouts, and the tread separating from the casing (those rings of tread, or "alligators" you see on the side of the highway are most often the result of radial truck tires, especially retreads, suffering this heat-induced tread separation). Off-road, radials will require more air pressure than bias ply tires to avoid excessive sidewall bulge resulting in sidewall splitting or the sidewall getting pinched between the rim and a rock. Purchase Considerations So now that we know the basics, we know enough to make our tire purchase decision ...well, almost! The last thing to cover is a few ideas on the specs we need to consider in selecting a tire. Once again I must emphasize the subjective nature of this . This is largely due to two things - the first is the fact that our hardcore offroading needs in a tire are completely and dramatically unlike any other tire users' - from race cars to motorbikes to tractors - there's no one else's use that even comes close to matching our needs. This is closely related to point two - which is: Ours is still a relatively "new" and "emerging" sport - a sport still in its infancy. As a result - there still aren't multi-million dollar competitive series and h | |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||