Also available as a download in .pdf format:
NCSU-Flow-Report.pdf
Report on the project entitled:
The Effect Of Chiari I Malformations On CSF Flow In
Cavalier King Charles Spaniels
Funded by the American Cavalier King Charles
Spaniel Club Charitable Trust
Stated objectives
1. Compare CSF flow velocity and distribution at
the level of the foramen magnum between
three groups of CKCS: normal CKCS, symptomatic CKCS with Chiari
malformations and asymptomatic CKCS with Chiari malformations.
2. Estimate the incidence of asymptomatic Chiari I malformations in
a small group of American CKCS.
3. Collect pedigree information and DNA from all study participants
in collaboration with Dr. Rusbridge's study on the genetics of this
disorder.
Original Budget: $10,000. This
was increased to $20,000 in view of the excellent response to
recruitment.
Summary of findings
There was an excellent response to the request for
participants and ultimately we imaged 59 dogs (rather than the 30-45
we had originally hoped for). Imaging studies took 30 minutes to
perform as long as everything went smoothly. The staff of the IAMS
Pet Imaging Center worked extremely hard to help us meet the target
number of patients to be imaged. We generated much more data than we
expected, as the range of skull morphologies (skull shape) present
required full characterization. The results of the study are
therefore divided into firstly the morphological findings and their
correlation to the presence of clinical signs and/or
syringohydromyelia (SHM) and secondly the findings of the CSF flow
measurements.
A) Morphological findings.
A set of definitions for the terms used has been
added to the end of this report for clarification. One of the major
problems we encountered was defining the limits of what is normal
versus abnormal. This has really not been done in a rigorous way
previously and so we hope that we have helped to increase the
knowledge in this area. Some of the parameters we evaluated we could
measure and therefore document in an objective manner (e.g. the
distance of cerebellar herniation) while others were more
subjective.
Of the 59 dogs that were imaged, 13 had
neurological signs consistent with a Chiari Malformation (22%) and
46 were neurologically normal (78%).
a) Cerebellar indentation and crowding (55 dogs:
93% of cases).
b) Cerebellar herniation through the foramen
magnum (50 dogs: 85% of cases). This varied from mild (1mm) to
severe (> 4mm).
c) Occipital dysplasia causing enlargement of the
foramen magnum (50 dogs: 85% of cases).
d) Syringohydromyelia (SHM) (22 dogs: 43% of
cases). It is important to note that 13 dogs with SHM did show any
clinical signs, they were neurologically normal.
e) Medullary kinking (33 dogs: 66% of cases).
f) A dorsal compressive lesion at the junction of
the first and second cervical vertebrae causing significant spinal
cord compression (12 dogs: 20% of cases). This was an unexpected
finding and was felt to playa role in the genesis of SHM in some
dogs with apparently mild indentation of the cerebellum.
The volume of the caudal fossa and of the total
cranial cavity were measured and the volume of the caudal fossa
expressed as a percentage of the total cranial cavity. The volume of
the caudal fossa is dictated by the occipital bone. a Both the
absolute volume of the caudal fossa and the ratio of the caudal
fossa to the whole cranial cavity were significantly smaller in dogs
showing clinical signs. This confirms that occipital hypoplasia
plays an important role in this disease syndrome in CKCS.
Statistical evaluation of all of the
morphological parameters was performed to determine the association
of individual abnormalities, and the abnormalities when considered
together with the presence of SHM and with the presence of clinical
signs.
a The following single parameters were
significantly associated with the presence and severity of
neurological signs:
Cerebellar indentation Syringohydromyelia
Volume of the caudal fossa (absolute value and ratio). a When
considered together, the following parameters were highly predictive
of neurological signs: Cerebellar indentation, medullary kinking
and ratio of caudal fossa volume/total cranial cavity volume.
Conclusions from the morphological study
1. The incidence of morphological abnormalities is
high.
2. The incidence of SHM is also relatively high
and is not always associated with clinical signs. In order to
determine whether SHM always ultimately causes clinical signs, we
will have to follow these dogs over time.
3. Occipital hypoplasia is present in dogs with
clinical signs.
4. This type of brain malformation is
multifactorial and includes abnormalities of the occipital bone
(hypoplasia and dysplasia) causing cerebellar crowding and
herniation, and abnormalities of the first and second cervical
vertebrae and the articulation of Cl with the occipital bone.
Medullary kinking appeared to result from both the occipital bone
abnormalities and abnormalities of the craniocervical junction.
B) CSF Flow Measurement Findings:
We were able to evaluate CSF flow in all of our study dogs using
Phase Velocity Contrast CINE MRI (PVC MRI), demonstrating the
usefulness of this imaging modality for analyzing cerebrospinal
fluid flow in veterinary patients. Peak velocities and CSF flow
patterns were assessed in the ventral and dorsal subarachnoid spaces
and within syrinxes at the following levels: just below the foramen
magnum and within the cervical spinal cord at the junction of the
second and third cervical vertebrae (C2-C3 disc). Statistical
evaluation of the observed flow characteristics was then performed.
Results were as follows:
CSF flow could be better visualized and more
effectively measured within the dorsal subarachnoid space if dogs
were positioned for imaging with their head and neck flexed,
mimicking a normal standing position, instead of the extended head
and neck position used routinely for MRI imaging.
Flow patterns could be visualized in both the
sagittal (in-plane) and transverse (through-plane) views at all
levels.
. Flow pattern observations included:
a) Obstruction to CSF flow was evident at the
level of the foramen magnum in the majority of CKCS when compared
with control dogs. This included clinically affected and unaffected
Cavaliers, and varied from mild obstructions to a complete absence
of observable flow at this level.
b) Obstruction to flow was also noted at the
level of the CI-C2 dorsal compression if this lesion was present.
b) CSF flow was present within syrinxes, and peak
flow velocities within syrinxes were often higher than within the
corresponding subarachnoid space.
c) Turbulent flow and high-velocity jets were seen
equally at the level of the foramen magnum, at the level of the
cervical spinal cord, and within syrinxes. They were also seen most
frequently in dogs with syringohydromyelia. . Peak velocities of CSF
flow were determined using transverse views. Velocity measurements
demonstrated the following:
a) Peak velocities within the ventral and dorsal
subarachnoid spaces were not significantly different between
clinically affected and unaffected CKCS. However, affected dogs
demonstrated a trend towards higher peak velocities within the
dorsal subarachnoid space at the level of the foramen magnum.
b) Peak velocities were not significantly
associated with the presence of syringohydromyelia at the level of
the foramen magnum. However, peak velocities of CSF flow in the
dorsal subarachnoid space were significantly lower at the level of
the C2-C3 junction in dogs with syringohydromyelia.
c) Additionally, when considered together, peak
velocities within the dorsal subarachnoid space at the level of the
foramen magnum and at the level of the cervical spinal cord were
highly predictive of the presence of a syrinx, such that:
i) Higher peak velocities at the foramen magnum
correlated with higher incidence of syringohydromyelia
ii) Lower peak velocities at the cervical spinal
cord correlated with higher incidence of syringohydromyelia.
d) We propose that this velocity gradient could be
the result of obstruction to flow at the level of the foramen magnum
and a relative post-obstructive expansion of the subarachnoid space
and subsequent slowing of flow at the level of the cervical spine.
e) Importantly, it was difficult to obtain
measurements at the point of maximum obstruction at the foramen
magnum, so measurements were obtained immediately caudal to this
point in all CKCS. This limitation may have affected our ability to
fully evaluate changes in peak velocities at the foramen magnum of
CKCS.
Conclusions from the CSF flow study:
1. CSF flow patterns and velocities can be
evaluated in dogs using PVC MR!.
2. Head position is important when performing
these studies. A flexed head and neck imitating normal standing
posture leads to a better determination of flow characteristics.
3. Obstruction to CSF flow at the foramen magnum
is a component of Chiari malformations in CKCS.
4. In affected dogs, CSF flow velocity is high at
the level of the FM and decreases over the C2-3 disc space,
demonstrating a gradient of flow.
5. Quantitative assessment of CSF flow velocities
may require more sophisticated software that is better able to
measure flow within small regions of interest by taking measurements
on a pixel - by - pixel basis, in order to allow evaluation at the
point of maximal obstruction (at the foramen magnum). Clinical
relevance of CSF flow findings:
1. PVC MRI could be used pre-operatively to
determine if obstruction(s) to CSF flow, turbulence, and/or
high-velocity jets are present in CKCS with morphologic changes
suggestive of a Chiari Malformation. This information could help
neurologists and owners when deciding whether the observed clinical
signs are due to the Chiari Malformation or if these morphologic
findings are non-clinical. Such information could prove very useful
in deciding the best course of treatment of such a patient.
2. Post-operatively, PVC MRI could be used to
determine if obstruction(s) to CSF flow have been relieved by
surgery or if additional surgery is warranted in patients with
residual clinical signs.
3. The clinical progress of the study participants
will be followed annually for 3 years and CSF flow velocities will
be re-correlated with the development of clinical signs. This will
be used to pursue a better understanding of velocity ranges that are
predictive of clinically apparent disease.
Budget
The initial budget was $10,000. This was increased
to $20,000 in view of the excellent response of breeders and owners
to the request for cases. The total outlay of the project was
$16,777.55: $15,000 on rental of MRI, anesthesia and MRI technician.
$1,777.55 was expended on supplies for DNA extraction and shipping
of samples to Dr Rusbridge's collaborators. $3,222.45 will be
returned to the sponsoring agency.
Dr. Sofia Cerda-Gonzalez, Neurology Clinical
Studies, College of Veterinary Medicine, NCSU
|