Music Snobbery: The Knife @ Webster Hall: Cuts Like a Knife, and It Feels Alright

CD Picks

Contact Me

E-Mail Me
Visit Me on Myspace

The Music

- Air
- Arcade Fire
- Arctic Monkeys
- Ash
- Athlete
- Nicole Atkins & The Sea
- Avalanches
- Basement Jaxx
- Beastie Boys
- Beck
- Belle & Sebastian
- Bentley Rhythm Ace
- Beta Band
- Bloc Party
- Blur
- BR5-49
- Broken Social Scene
- The Brunettes
- Neko Case
- The Charlatans
- Chemical Brothers
- Clap Your Hands Say Yeah
- Cornershop
- Graham Coxon
- Daft Punk
- Danger Mouse
- Death Cab for Cutie
- The Decemberists
- De La Soul
- The Delgados
- Dizzee Rascal
- Doves
- Editors
- Elastica
- Faithless
- Fatboy Slim
- Feist
- Flaming Lips
- Franz Ferdinand
- Gorillaz
- Gotan Project
- The Go! Team
- Grand National
- Groove Armada
- The Guillemots
- Hard-Fi
- PJ Harvey
- Interpol
- Chris Isaak
- Ivy
- Jesus & Mary Chain
- Joy Zipper
- Kaiser Chiefs
- Kings of Convenience
- Kraftwerk
- Leftfield
- The Libertines/Dirty Pretty Things
- Luna
- Luscious Jackson
- Madness
- Magnetic Fields
- Manic Street Preachers
- Man or Astroman?
- Massive Attack
- Mates of State
- M83
- M.I.A.
- Moby
- Morcheeba
- Van Morrison
- Morning After Girls
- My Bloody Valentine
- My Morning Jacket
- New Order/Joy Division
- The New Pornographers
- Oasis
- Of Montreal
- Oingo Boingo
- Olds 97
- Beth Orton
- Pavement/Stephen Malkmus
- Phoenix
- Pixies
- Portishead
- Postal Service
- Primal Scream
- Prince
- Prodigy
- Public Enemy
- Pulp
- Radiohead
- The Rakes
- The Raveonettes
- Razorlight
- R.E.M.
- Rilo Kiley/Jenny Lewis
- The Roots
- Royksopp
- Saint Etienne
- Secret Machines
- DJ Shadow
- The Shins
- Sleater-Kinney
- Sons & Daughters
- South
- Southern Culture of the Skids
- John Spencer Blues Explosion
- Spiritualized
- Bruce Springsteen
- The Smiths/Morrissey
- Stars
- Starsailor
- Stereolab
- St. Germain
- Stone Roses
- The Streets
- The Strokes
- The Sundays
- Super Furry Animals
- Supergrass
- They Might Be Giants
- Tosca
- Travis
- A Tribe Called Quest
- Underworld
- U.N.K.L.E.
- U2
- The Verve/Richard Ashcroft
- We Are Scientists
- The White Stripes
- Wilco
- Lucinda Williams
- XTC
- Yeah Yeah Yeahs
- Zero 7
- All the classics that a person like me should have in his collection

Like Minded Blogs

Crackers United
Brooklyn Vegan
Heart on a Stick
The Music Slut
Product Shop NYC
Thighs Wide Shut
The Modern Age
Stereogum
Yeti Don't Dance

Hall of Fame

Bands I've Seen Four Times or More:
- Nicole Atkins & The Sea
- Beck
- Blur
- Death Cab for Cutie
- Doves
- Editors
- Franz Ferdinand
- Gorillaz
- The Grates
- Immaculate Machine
- The New Pornographers
- Phoenix
- Radiohead
- The Roots
- Secret Machines
- Bruce Springsteen
- Supergrass
- They Might Be Giants
- Yeah Yeah Yeahs

« The Sunshine Underground/The Holloways/The Pigeon Detectives/Pull Tiger Tail @ KOKO, Oct. 24 | Main | The Pinker Tones/Earlimart/Lavender Diamond/Death Vessel @ NorthSix »

November 01, 2006

The Knife @ Webster Hall: Cuts Like a Knife, and It Feels Alright

It's the Blue Man Group meets Kraftwerk with art inspired by David Lynch. That's how I sum it up.

The line that stretched up the block was a sure sign that The Knife are no longer relegated to that category of obscure bands to name drop to impress your hipster friends. Tonight, after years of hearing about them and wanting to experience them live, Karin and Olof made their U.S. debut. It was packed, the anticipation was immense, the stage was set and the show was over in about 50-60 minutes.

Setlist:

Pass This On
The Captain
We Share Our Mother’s Health
You Make Me Like Charity
Marble House
Forest Families
Kino
Heartbeats
Silent Shout
From Off To On
Encore: Like a Pen

You know already the M.O. of The Knife and their live show -- it's not a concert, but more like performance art you can sometimes dance to. Like in their promo material, the brother and sister duo wear masks and outfits to make them look anonymous and androgynous. The point, as Karin pointed out in our interview, was that we should pay attention to the visuals and music and not what they are doing.

I look upon the night knowing that it's not going to be an involving affair where you feel one with the performer. With the front and rear projection and the obscured band members, it creates a certain disconnect with the artists. On the other, tonight's show was entertaining and interesting. The projections are the show with the music serving as a compliment to them. Karin and Olof are there pushing buttons, but I doubt they are doing anything major to manipulate the music. Olof was banging away on some electronic pads, but it seemed mysteriously out-of-sync with the music. Karin's vocals were live, going to her natural voice to change the pitch to make her sound masculine.

I'm sure those who have seen or will see them on their brief tour will remember the creepy heads that appeared on stage. As first, it was a human head singing along that turned into a skull. It's like the techno version of the great Oz. "I am the great and mighty Oz. Do not look behind the curtain. I order you to dance." On the right side of the stage, we had the singing heads of a monkey and lizard creatures.

Andreas Nilsson oversees the visual aspect of the performance. Those singing heads were a tad over the top, but some of his animation choices fitted the music perfectly. The best place to watch the show was the back, because the front screen served as a frame for what was on stage and shown behind it. Even if you thought that the show was missing a little more kick, you have to admit that the modern art aspect of the show was interesting and different.

As we all know, modern art makes me want to rock out. I would say that The Knife let themselves to get their dance on for a handful of tracks like Silent Shout, Like a Pen and You Make Me Like Charity. I was hoping Heartbeats would be done normally, but it was remixed to kind of sound like Nine Inch Nail's Closer. Whatever they did with it, it took away from the song's romanticism and made it sort of unsexy and dark.

Silent Shout was the highlight for me. The duo even let themselves cut loose, which gave the crowd the added incentive to dance around a bit. It inevitable that the crowd is going to respond to music that they get into, so I'm feeling a tug between that dance club aspect and the side that's more dark and introspective.

In all, I left with a positive feeling. It takes guts to hide the aspects we come to enjoy in live shows, and make it more about the visuals, than about the people pushing the buttons. I'm hoping with a few more albums under their belt, they can expand on their stage show and make it a little more engaging and accessible.

This was the place to be tonight. The guys from Stereogum, ProductShop NYC and Yeti were all in attendance as well. Yeah, it was one of those "calling all bloggers" happenings.

As for me, my prognosis is a torn ligament and dislocated knee cap. Yup, I screwed up my knee big time. I walked to the venue with no problem, but standing in place for a bit was uncomfortable. By the end, I was walking out with some discomfort. Thus, I bailed out seeing some CMJ shows and parties tonight. I just have to take it easy and keep the rocking down to a minimum.

November 01, 2006 at 11:31 PM | Permalink

Comments

To put it simply the show/music/performance/visuals were amazing. Without a doubt one of my favorite shows of all time. As for Olof drumming out of sync, i disagree. I could see how someone not very close to the stage would think this, because it was often difficult to figure out which sounds the drum pads were triggering. I'm pretty certain that he was actually playing. Also i couldn't tell what else he had back there but he was definitely grooving with some other equipment. If anyone knows anything about that I would surely appreciate. I feel bad for any fan that missed the show! Brilliant! Wish it could have lasted longer!

Posted by: Able & Baker | November 03, 2006 at 07:16 PM

Search

Web MusicSnobbery

Past 5 Gigs

The Good, The Bad and The Queen @ The Roundhouse
The Grates/Victorian English Gentleman's Club/The Bishops @ King's College
The Sunshine Underground/The Holloways/The Pigeon Detectives/Pull Tiger Tail
Tilly and the Wall/Northern State @ Bowery Ballroom
Jenny Lewis with the Watson Twins @ Town Hall

Past 5 Interviews

The Knife
Johnny Borrell of Razorlight
Mani of Primal Scream and The Stone Roses
Lady Sovereign
Patience Hodgson of The Grates

Past 5 Top 5

Top 5 Musical Moments in Apocalypse Now
Top 5 Moments in Luna's Tell Me Do You Miss Me
The High Fidelity Cultural Reference Guide, Vol. I: The Top Five Lists
Top 5 Acts That Must Be Defeated During the Musical Revolution
Top 5 "I" Bands

Music Snobbery

Do I listen to pop music because I was miserable? Or was I miserable because I listened to pop music?