FROM THE ARCHIVE:
VOLUME 10 ISSUE 1
Ex iniuria ius oritur: are we moving towards international legitimation of forcible humanitarian countermeasures in the world community?
ARTICLE BY A CASSESE, Cassese comments on the article by Simma, also in this issue, on the legitimacy of the use of force by NATO in the Kosovo crisis. The author agrees with Simma that NATO's action falls outside the scope of the United Nations Charter and, by that token, is illegal under international law. This breach is not a negligible one and it is not to be countenanced merely by referring to its exceptional character and by stating that it should not be seen as setting a precedent. The author explores the notion that NATO's action may nevertheless be taken as evidence of an emerging doctrine in international law allowing the use of forcible countermeasures to impede a state from committing large-scale atrocities on its own territory, in circumstances where the Security Council is incapable of responding adequately to the crisis. The author argues that where a number of stringent conditions are met, a customary rule may emerge which would legitimize the use of force by a group of states in the absence of prior authorization by the Security Council. This is subject to various caveats, including the need to bear in mind the threat to global security which is inevitably involved in the use of force without such authorization.
READ MORE
About the EJIL
Welcome to the website of one of the world’s leading international law journals. The EJIL was established in 1990 by a small group of scholars based at the European University Institute, the Universities of Florence, Munich and Paris II and the Michigan Law School. The Journal has grown since then in size, strength and reputation, but the Editors’ original vision remains unchanged. About the EJIL
- Subscribe to the EJIL
- Join our email list
- Submitting manuscripts
- Submitting book reviews
- Book Reviews
- Books Received
- International Law Book Reviews Online
- European Law Book Reviews Online
Links
- International Law Links
- Jean Monnet Working Papers (NYU/EUI)
- IILJ Working Papers
The free viewer (Acrobat Reader) for PDF file is available at the Adobe Systems
News
No news available
In The Current Issue: Vol. 22 (2011) No. 4
Editorial
- JHHW,
Nino - In His Own Words; In this Issue; The Last Page and Roaming Charges ( JHHW abstract) (free fulltext)
Articles
- Jaye Ellis,
General Principles and Comparative Law (Jaye Ellis abstract)
- Thilo Rensmann,
Munich Alumni and the Evolution of International Human Rights Law (Thilo Rensmann abstract) (free fulltext)
- Anastasios Gourgourinis,
General/Particular International Law and Primary/Secondary Rules: Unitary Terminology of a Fragmented System (Anastasios Gourgourinis abstract)
- Daphné Richemond-Barak,
Regulating War: A Taxonomy in Global Administrative Law (Daphné Richemond-Barak abstract)
Critical Review of International Jurisprudence
- Sonia Morano-Foadi, Stelios Andreadakis,
The Convergence of the European Legal System in the Treatment of Third Country Nationals in Europe: The ECJ and ECtHR Jurisprudence (Stelios Andreadakis abstract)
Critical Review of International Governance
- Abigail C. Deshman,
Horizontal Review between International Organizations: Why, How, and Who Cares about Corporate Regulatory Capture (Abigail C. Deshman abstract)
Roaming Charges : Places of Worship: Piazza Duomo Milano
- Roaming Charges: Places of Worship: Piazza Duomo Milano (Abigail C. Deshman abstract) (free fulltext)
EJIL : Debate!
- Roda Mushkat,
The Dynamics of International Legal Regime Formation: The Sino-British Joint Declaration on the Question of Hong Kong Revisited (Roda Mushkat abstract)
- Kevin Y. L. Tan,
The Dynamics of International Legal Regime Formation: The Sino-British Joint Declaration on the Question of Hong Kong Revisited: A Reply to Roda Mushkat (Kevin Y. L. Tan abstract)
- Roda Mushkat,
The Dynamics of International Legal Regime Formation: The Sino-British Joint Declaration on the Question of Hong Kong Revisited: A Rejoinder to Kevin Tan (Roda Mushkat abstract)
EJIL : Debate! Doing Justice to the Political
- Bas Schotel,
Doing Justice to the Political. The International Criminal Court in Uganda and Sudan: A Reply to Sarah Nouwen and Wouter Werner (Bas Schotel abstract)
- Sarah M. H. Nouwen, Wouter G. Werner,
Doing Justice to the Political: The International Criminal Court in Uganda and Sudan: A Rejoinder to Bas Schotel (Wouter G. Werner abstract)
Impressions
- Philip Allott,
On First Understanding Plato's Republic (Philip Allott abstract) (free fulltext)
Book Reviews
- Antonio Cassese. Five Masters of International Law: Conversations with R-J Dupuy, E Jimenez de Arechaga, R Jennings, L Henkin and O Schachter
(Jan KlabbersFree fulltext)
- Sir Hersch Lauterpacht. The Function of Law in the International Community
(Isabel FeichtnerFree fulltext)
- Samantha Besson, John Tasioulas (eds). The Philosophy of International Law
(Isabelle LeyFree fulltext)
- Peter G. Danchin, Horst Fischer (eds). United Nations Reform and the New Collective Security
, Spencer Zifcak. United Nations Reform: Heading North or South?
(Anne-Laurence Graf-BrugèreFree fulltext)
- Gerd Hankel. Das Totungsverbot im Krieg
(Sigrid MehringFree fulltext)
- Olivier Corten. The Law Against War
(Irène CouzigouFree fulltext)
- Jane McAdam (ed.). Climate Change and Displacement. Multidisciplinary Perspectives
(Jenny Grote StoutenburgFree fulltext)
- Peter H. Sand. Atoll Diego Garcia: Naturschutz zwischen Menschenrecht und Machtpolitik
(Ebrahim AfsahFree fulltext)
- Gregory C. Shaffer, Ricardo Melendez-Ortiz (eds). Dispute Settlement at the WTO: The Developing Country Experience
(Mary E. FooterFree fulltext)
- Rudiger Wolfrum, Peter-Tobias Stoll, Holger P. Hestermeyer (eds). WTO: Trade in Goods
(Sungjoon ChoFree fulltext)
- Michael P. Scharf, Paul R. Williams. Shaping Foreign Policy in Times of Crisis: the Role of International Law and the State Department Legal Adviser
(Andre StemmetFree fulltext)
- Giuseppe Martinico, Oreste Pollicino (eds). The National Judicial Treatment of the ECHR and EU Laws. A Comparative Constitutional Perspective
(Alessandro ChechiFree fulltext)
Briefly Noted
- Alexandra Kemmerer,
Ulrich Fastenrath, Rudolf Geiger, Daniel-Erasmus Khan, Andreas Paulus, Sabine von Schorlemer, Christoph Vedder (eds). From Bilateralism to Community Interest. Essays in Honour of Judge Bruno Simma (Alexandra Kemmerer abstract) (free fulltext)
The Last Page
- Jonathan Shaw,
On Reading Horace Odes 3.2 with Rusty Latin (Jonathan Shaw abstract) (free fulltext)
Latest from EJIL:Talk
20/03/2012
Colleagues Wanted: Oxford Advertises Two International Law Positions
DAPO AKANDE
19/03/2012
Call for Papers: International Human Rights Law Review
MARKO MILANOVIC
15/03/2012
ICC Delivers Its First Judgment: The Lubanga Case and Classification of Conflicts in Situations of Occupation
DAPO AKANDE
15/03/2012
International Tribunal for the Law of Sea’s First Judgment on Maritime Delimitation
DAPO AKANDE
15/03/2012
International Law Weekend 2012: Call for Papers and Panels
RUTH WEDGWOOD
14/03/2012
R v Mohammed Gul: Are You a Terrorist if You Support the Syrian Insurgency?
KIMBERLEY TRAPP
13/03/2012
Venice Academy of Human Rights 2012
MARKO MILANOVIC
13/03/2012
Call for Papers: The ICC at 10
MARKO MILANOVIC
13/03/2012
Legality of Drone Strikes in Pakistan to be Tested in English Courts?
DAPO AKANDE
12/03/2012
Judging Judges: A Statistical Exercise
MARKO MILANOVIC